2009:Audio Classical Composer Identification Results

From MIREX Wiki

Introduction

These are the results for the 2009 running of the Audio Classical Composer Identification task. For background information about this task set please refer to the 2007:Audio Classical Composer Identification page.

The data set consisted of 2772 30 second audio clips. The composers represented were:

  1. Bach
  2. Beethoven
  3. Brahms
  4. Chopin
  5. Dvorak
  6. Handel
  7. Haydn
  8. Mendelssohnn
  9. Mozart
  10. Schubert
  11. Vivaldi

The goal was to correctly identify the composer who wrote each of the pieces represented.

General Legend

Team ID

ANO= Anonymous
BP1= Juan José Burred, Geoffroy Peeters (file)
BP2 = Juan José Burred, Geoffroy Peeters (tw)
CL1 = Chuan Cao, Ming Li
CL2 = Chuan Cao, Ming Li
GP = Geoffroy Peeters
GT1 = George Tzanetakis (mono)
GT2 = George Tzanetakis (stereo)
GLR1 = Andrei Grecu, Thomas Lidy, Andreas Rauber (full)
GLR2 = Andrei Grecu, Thomas Lidy, Andreas Rauber (template)
HNOS1 = Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tcca)
HNOS2 = Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tcck)
HNOS3 = Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tccl)
HNOS4 = Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tcpk)
HW1 = Huaxin Wang
HW2 = Huaxin Wang
VA1 = Thomas Lidy, Andrei Grecu, Andreas Rauber, A. Pertusa, P. J. Ponce de León, J. M. Iñesta (WMV)
VA2 = Thomas Lidy, Andrei Grecu, Andreas Rauber, A. Pertusa, P. J. Ponce de León, J. M. Iñesta (BWWV)
LZG = Yi Liu, Tao Zheng, Yue Gao (RUC_1)
RK1 = Preeti Rao, Sujeet Kini
SS = Klaus Seyerlehner, Markus Schedl
TTOS = Emiru Tsunoo, George Tzanetakis, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama
MTG1 = Nicolas Wack, Enric Guaus, Cyril Laurier, Owen Meyers, Ricard Marxer, Dmitry Bogdanov, Joan Serrà, Perfecto Herrera (false, rca)
MTG2 = Nicolas Wack, Enric Guaus, Cyril Laurier, Owen Meyers, Ricard Marxer, Dmitry Bogdanov, Joan Serrà, Perfecto Herrera (true, rca)
MTG3 = Nicolas Wack, Enric Guaus, Cyril Laurier, Owen Meyers, Ricard Marxer, Dmitry Bogdanov, Joan Serrà, Perfecto Herrera (false, simca)
MTG4 = Nicolas Wack, Enric Guaus, Cyril Laurier, Owen Meyers, Ricard Marxer, Dmitry Bogdanov, Joan Serrà, Perfecto Herrera (true, simca)
MTG5 = Nicolas Wack, Enric Guaus, Cyril Laurier, Owen Meyers, Ricard Marxer, Dmitry Bogdanov, Joan Serrà, Perfecto Herrera (false, svm)
MTG6 = Nicolas Wack, Enric Guaus, Cyril Laurier, Owen Meyers, Ricard Marxer, Dmitry Bogdanov, Joan Serrà, Perfecto Herrera (true, svm)
XLZZG = Jieping Xu, Yi Liu, Tao Zheng, Chao Zhen, Yue Gao (RUC_1)
XZZ = JiePing Xu, Chao Zhen, Tao Zheng (RUC_2)

Overall Summary Results

Raw Classification Accuracy Averaged Over Three Train/Test Folds

Participant Mean Accuracy
ANO 41.77%
BP1 55.66%
BP2 54.76%
CL1 60.97%
CL2 60.03%
GLR1 55.34%
GLR2 45.92%
GP 48.85%
GT1 43.69%
GT2 51.48%
HNOS1 43.33%
HNOS2 15.84%
HNOS3 42.24%
HNOS4 29.04%
HW1 56.35%
HW2 53.10%
LZG 54.40%
MTG1 54.73%
MTG2 62.05%
MTG3 48.12%
MTG4 48.20%
MTG5 49.75%
MTG6 50.36%
RK1 48.41%
SS 52.56%
TTOS 44.37%
VA1 53.57%
VA2 53.57%
XLZZG 53.54%
XZZ 57.18%

download these results as csv

Accuracy Across Folds

Classification fold ANO BP1 BP2 CL1 CL2 GLR1 GLR2 GP GT1 GT2 HNOS1 HNOS2 HNOS3 HNOS4 HW1 HW2 LZG MTG1 MTG2 MTG3 MTG4 MTG5 MTG6 RK1 SS TTOS VA1 VA2 XLZZG XZZ
0 0.413 0.562 0.568 0.606 0.594 0.564 0.460 0.490 0.447 0.534 0.438 0.142 0.425 0.298 0.575 0.542 0.554 0.537 0.629 0.484 0.485 0.501 0.505 0.503 0.526 0.460 0.537 0.537 0.547 0.590
1 0.436 0.568 0.523 0.607 0.597 0.526 0.458 0.485 0.427 0.511 0.406 0.167 0.418 0.279 0.564 0.527 0.548 0.560 0.620 0.481 0.473 0.496 0.504 0.478 0.527 0.425 0.530 0.530 0.530 0.552
2 0.404 0.540 0.552 0.616 0.609 0.570 0.460 0.490 0.436 0.500 0.456 0.167 0.424 0.294 0.552 0.524 0.530 0.545 0.613 0.479 0.488 0.496 0.501 0.471 0.524 0.446 0.540 0.540 0.529 0.574

download these results as csv

Accuracy Across Categories

Class ANO BP1 BP2 CL1 CL2 GLR1 GLR2 GP GT1 GT2 HNOS1 HNOS2 HNOS3 HNOS4 HW1 HW2 LZG MTG1 MTG2 MTG3 MTG4 MTG5 MTG6 RK1 SS TTOS VA1 VA2 XLZZG XZZ
bach 0.607 0.750 0.766 0.786 0.790 0.750 0.599 0.639 0.544 0.615 0.552 0.000 0.512 0.036 0.698 0.663 0.730 0.774 0.778 0.635 0.587 0.631 0.659 0.659 0.702 0.603 0.687 0.687 0.762 0.782
beethoven 0.246 0.552 0.544 0.560 0.548 0.440 0.385 0.321 0.437 0.528 0.377 0.742 0.329 0.500 0.429 0.365 0.409 0.488 0.548 0.417 0.433 0.448 0.433 0.357 0.393 0.440 0.262 0.262 0.409 0.496
brahms 0.365 0.579 0.365 0.460 0.472 0.393 0.310 0.282 0.238 0.409 0.282 0.306 0.282 0.107 0.397 0.325 0.381 0.528 0.607 0.321 0.337 0.456 0.413 0.333 0.500 0.278 0.333 0.333 0.381 0.373
chopin 0.706 0.750 0.786 0.869 0.865 0.889 0.722 0.905 0.774 0.794 0.671 0.000 0.706 0.714 0.913 0.921 0.869 0.659 0.758 0.726 0.742 0.702 0.738 0.897 0.802 0.770 0.889 0.889 0.857 0.917
dvorak 0.397 0.532 0.464 0.611 0.583 0.504 0.417 0.437 0.417 0.556 0.425 0.040 0.405 0.349 0.437 0.460 0.484 0.452 0.472 0.361 0.333 0.385 0.425 0.464 0.496 0.385 0.484 0.484 0.464 0.571
handel 0.425 0.524 0.659 0.623 0.599 0.560 0.468 0.488 0.365 0.401 0.389 0.008 0.397 0.123 0.611 0.603 0.587 0.563 0.655 0.548 0.560 0.472 0.448 0.583 0.480 0.417 0.583 0.583 0.567 0.563
haydn 0.492 0.639 0.675 0.690 0.683 0.742 0.627 0.635 0.528 0.623 0.556 0.504 0.552 0.690 0.806 0.782 0.643 0.631 0.726 0.575 0.587 0.595 0.623 0.698 0.540 0.524 0.690 0.690 0.635 0.714
mendelssohnn 0.361 0.444 0.440 0.460 0.456 0.397 0.325 0.341 0.429 0.440 0.377 0.000 0.397 0.107 0.480 0.460 0.508 0.460 0.556 0.353 0.361 0.405 0.409 0.452 0.468 0.385 0.496 0.496 0.480 0.500
mozart 0.230 0.325 0.298 0.417 0.421 0.365 0.278 0.274 0.274 0.357 0.313 0.000 0.250 0.036 0.282 0.206 0.341 0.437 0.492 0.377 0.349 0.369 0.389 0.000 0.401 0.317 0.333 0.333 0.361 0.365
schubert 0.310 0.389 0.389 0.484 0.468 0.373 0.290 0.306 0.230 0.353 0.278 0.040 0.238 0.194 0.429 0.357 0.361 0.389 0.532 0.381 0.389 0.381 0.361 0.266 0.437 0.206 0.409 0.409 0.341 0.310
vivaldi 0.456 0.639 0.639 0.746 0.718 0.675 0.631 0.746 0.571 0.587 0.548 0.103 0.579 0.337 0.718 0.698 0.671 0.639 0.702 0.599 0.623 0.627 0.643 0.615 0.563 0.556 0.726 0.726 0.631 0.698

download these results as csv

Friedman's Tests for Significant Differences

Classes vs. System Tukey-Kramer HSD Multi-Comparisons

The Friedman test was run in MATLAB against the average accuracy for each class. The Tukey-Kramer HSD multi-comparison data below was generated using the following MATLAB instruction. Command:
[c, m, h, gnames] = multicompare(stats, 'ctype', 'tukey-kramer', 'estimate', 'friedman', 'alpha', 0.05);

TeamID TeamID Lowerbound Mean Upperbound Significance
ANO BP1 -14.425 -0.364 13.698 FALSE
ANO BP2 -13.107 0.955 15.016 FALSE
ANO CL1 -10.834 3.227 17.289 FALSE
ANO CL2 -9.607 4.455 18.516 FALSE
ANO GLR1 -7.744 6.318 20.380 FALSE
ANO GLR2 -8.425 5.636 19.698 FALSE
ANO GP -7.334 6.727 20.789 FALSE
ANO GT1 -7.425 6.636 20.698 FALSE
ANO GT2 -7.744 6.318 20.380 FALSE
ANO HNOS1 -7.653 6.409 20.471 FALSE
ANO HNOS2 -7.653 6.409 20.471 FALSE
ANO HNOS3 -6.016 8.046 22.107 FALSE
ANO HNOS4 -5.744 8.318 22.380 FALSE
ANO HW1 -5.971 8.091 22.153 FALSE
ANO HW2 -3.789 10.273 24.334 FALSE
ANO LZG -3.107 10.954 25.016 FALSE
ANO MTG1 -1.789 12.273 26.334 FALSE
ANO MTG2 -0.789 13.273 27.334 FALSE
ANO MTG3 -2.516 11.546 25.607 FALSE
ANO MTG4 0.075 14.136 28.198 TRUE
ANO MTG5 0.438 14.500 28.562 TRUE
ANO MTG6 3.075 17.136 31.198 TRUE
ANO RK1 3.938 18.000 32.062 TRUE
ANO SS 4.120 18.182 32.243 TRUE
ANO TTOS 5.256 19.318 33.380 TRUE
ANO VA1 5.938 20.000 34.062 TRUE
ANO VA2 5.484 19.546 33.607 TRUE
ANO XLZZG 5.575 19.636 33.698 TRUE
ANO XZZ 7.711 21.773 35.834 TRUE
BP1 BP2 -12.743 1.318 15.380 FALSE
BP1 CL1 -10.471 3.591 17.653 FALSE
BP1 CL2 -9.243 4.818 18.880 FALSE
BP1 GLR1 -7.380 6.682 20.744 FALSE
BP1 GLR2 -8.062 6.000 20.062 FALSE
BP1 GP -6.971 7.091 21.153 FALSE
BP1 GT1 -7.062 7.000 21.062 FALSE
BP1 GT2 -7.380 6.682 20.744 FALSE
BP1 HNOS1 -7.289 6.773 20.834 FALSE
BP1 HNOS2 -7.289 6.773 20.834 FALSE
BP1 HNOS3 -5.653 8.409 22.471 FALSE
BP1 HNOS4 -5.380 8.682 22.744 FALSE
BP1 HW1 -5.607 8.454 22.516 FALSE
BP1 HW2 -3.425 10.636 24.698 FALSE
BP1 LZG -2.744 11.318 25.380 FALSE
BP1 MTG1 -1.425 12.636 26.698 FALSE
BP1 MTG2 -0.425 13.636 27.698 FALSE
BP1 MTG3 -2.153 11.909 25.971 FALSE
BP1 MTG4 0.438 14.500 28.562 TRUE
BP1 MTG5 0.802 14.864 28.925 TRUE
BP1 MTG6 3.438 17.500 31.562 TRUE
BP1 RK1 4.302 18.364 32.425 TRUE
BP1 SS 4.484 18.546 32.607 TRUE
BP1 TTOS 5.620 19.682 33.743 TRUE
BP1 VA1 6.302 20.364 34.425 TRUE
BP1 VA2 5.847 19.909 33.971 TRUE
BP1 XLZZG 5.938 20.000 34.062 TRUE
BP1 XZZ 8.075 22.136 36.198 TRUE
BP2 CL1 -11.789 2.273 16.334 FALSE
BP2 CL2 -10.562 3.500 17.562 FALSE
BP2 GLR1 -8.698 5.364 19.425 FALSE
BP2 GLR2 -9.380 4.682 18.744 FALSE
BP2 GP -8.289 5.773 19.834 FALSE
BP2 GT1 -8.380 5.682 19.744 FALSE
BP2 GT2 -8.698 5.364 19.425 FALSE
BP2 HNOS1 -8.607 5.455 19.516 FALSE
BP2 HNOS2 -8.607 5.455 19.516 FALSE
BP2 HNOS3 -6.971 7.091 21.153 FALSE
BP2 HNOS4 -6.698 7.364 21.425 FALSE
BP2 HW1 -6.925 7.136 21.198 FALSE
BP2 HW2 -4.744 9.318 23.380 FALSE
BP2 LZG -4.062 10.000 24.062 FALSE
BP2 MTG1 -2.744 11.318 25.380 FALSE
BP2 MTG2 -1.744 12.318 26.380 FALSE
BP2 MTG3 -3.471 10.591 24.653 FALSE
BP2 MTG4 -0.880 13.182 27.244 FALSE
BP2 MTG5 -0.516 13.546 27.607 FALSE
BP2 MTG6 2.120 16.182 30.244 TRUE
BP2 RK1 2.984 17.046 31.107 TRUE
BP2 SS 3.166 17.227 31.289 TRUE
BP2 TTOS 4.302 18.364 32.425 TRUE
BP2 VA1 4.984 19.046 33.107 TRUE
BP2 VA2 4.529 18.591 32.653 TRUE
BP2 XLZZG 4.620 18.682 32.743 TRUE
BP2 XZZ 6.756 20.818 34.880 TRUE
CL1 CL2 -12.834 1.227 15.289 FALSE
CL1 GLR1 -10.971 3.091 17.153 FALSE
CL1 GLR2 -11.653 2.409 16.471 FALSE
CL1 GP -10.562 3.500 17.562 FALSE
CL1 GT1 -10.653 3.409 17.471 FALSE
CL1 GT2 -10.971 3.091 17.153 FALSE
CL1 HNOS1 -10.880 3.182 17.244 FALSE
CL1 HNOS2 -10.880 3.182 17.244 FALSE
CL1 HNOS3 -9.243 4.818 18.880 FALSE
CL1 HNOS4 -8.971 5.091 19.153 FALSE
CL1 HW1 -9.198 4.864 18.925 FALSE
CL1 HW2 -7.016 7.045 21.107 FALSE
CL1 LZG -6.334 7.727 21.789 FALSE
CL1 MTG1 -5.016 9.046 23.107 FALSE
CL1 MTG2 -4.016 10.046 24.107 FALSE
CL1 MTG3 -5.744 8.318 22.380 FALSE
CL1 MTG4 -3.153 10.909 24.971 FALSE
CL1 MTG5 -2.789 11.273 25.334 FALSE
CL1 MTG6 -0.153 13.909 27.971 FALSE
CL1 RK1 0.711 14.773 28.834 TRUE
CL1 SS 0.893 14.954 29.016 TRUE
CL1 TTOS 2.029 16.091 30.153 TRUE
CL1 VA1 2.711 16.773 30.834 TRUE
CL1 VA2 2.256 16.318 30.380 TRUE
CL1 XLZZG 2.347 16.409 30.471 TRUE
CL1 XZZ 4.484 18.546 32.607 TRUE
CL2 GLR1 -12.198 1.864 15.925 FALSE
CL2 GLR2 -12.880 1.182 15.243 FALSE
CL2 GP -11.789 2.273 16.334 FALSE
CL2 GT1 -11.880 2.182 16.244 FALSE
CL2 GT2 -12.198 1.864 15.925 FALSE
CL2 HNOS1 -12.107 1.954 16.016 FALSE
CL2 HNOS2 -12.107 1.954 16.016 FALSE
CL2 HNOS3 -10.471 3.591 17.653 FALSE
CL2 HNOS4 -10.198 3.864 17.925 FALSE
CL2 HW1 -10.425 3.636 17.698 FALSE
CL2 HW2 -8.243 5.818 19.880 FALSE
CL2 LZG -7.562 6.500 20.562 FALSE
CL2 MTG1 -6.244 7.818 21.880 FALSE
CL2 MTG2 -5.244 8.818 22.880 FALSE
CL2 MTG3 -6.971 7.091 21.153 FALSE
CL2 MTG4 -4.380 9.682 23.744 FALSE
CL2 MTG5 -4.016 10.046 24.107 FALSE
CL2 MTG6 -1.380 12.682 26.744 FALSE
CL2 RK1 -0.516 13.546 27.607 FALSE
CL2 SS -0.334 13.727 27.789 FALSE
CL2 TTOS 0.802 14.864 28.925 TRUE
CL2 VA1 1.484 15.546 29.607 TRUE
CL2 VA2 1.029 15.091 29.153 TRUE
CL2 XLZZG 1.120 15.182 29.244 TRUE
CL2 XZZ 3.256 17.318 31.380 TRUE
GLR1 GLR2 -14.743 -0.682 13.380 FALSE
GLR1 GP -13.653 0.409 14.471 FALSE
GLR1 GT1 -13.743 0.318 14.380 FALSE
GLR1 GT2 -14.062 0.000 14.062 FALSE
GLR1 HNOS1 -13.971 0.091 14.153 FALSE
GLR1 HNOS2 -13.971 0.091 14.153 FALSE
GLR1 HNOS3 -12.334 1.727 15.789 FALSE
GLR1 HNOS4 -12.062 2.000 16.062 FALSE
GLR1 HW1 -12.289 1.773 15.834 FALSE
GLR1 HW2 -10.107 3.954 18.016 FALSE
GLR1 LZG -9.425 4.636 18.698 FALSE
GLR1 MTG1 -8.107 5.955 20.016 FALSE
GLR1 MTG2 -7.107 6.955 21.016 FALSE
GLR1 MTG3 -8.834 5.227 19.289 FALSE
GLR1 MTG4 -6.244 7.818 21.880 FALSE
GLR1 MTG5 -5.880 8.182 22.244 FALSE
GLR1 MTG6 -3.244 10.818 24.880 FALSE
GLR1 RK1 -2.380 11.682 25.744 FALSE
GLR1 SS -2.198 11.864 25.925 FALSE
GLR1 TTOS -1.062 13.000 27.062 FALSE
GLR1 VA1 -0.380 13.682 27.744 FALSE
GLR1 VA2 -0.834 13.227 27.289 FALSE
GLR1 XLZZG -0.744 13.318 27.380 FALSE
GLR1 XZZ 1.393 15.454 29.516 TRUE
GLR2 GP -12.971 1.091 15.153 FALSE
GLR2 GT1 -13.062 1.000 15.062 FALSE
GLR2 GT2 -13.380 0.682 14.743 FALSE
GLR2 HNOS1 -13.289 0.773 14.834 FALSE
GLR2 HNOS2 -13.289 0.773 14.834 FALSE
GLR2 HNOS3 -11.653 2.409 16.471 FALSE
GLR2 HNOS4 -11.380 2.682 16.744 FALSE
GLR2 HW1 -11.607 2.454 16.516 FALSE
GLR2 HW2 -9.425 4.636 18.698 FALSE
GLR2 LZG -8.743 5.318 19.380 FALSE
GLR2 MTG1 -7.425 6.636 20.698 FALSE
GLR2 MTG2 -6.425 7.636 21.698 FALSE
GLR2 MTG3 -8.153 5.909 19.971 FALSE
GLR2 MTG4 -5.562 8.500 22.562 FALSE
GLR2 MTG5 -5.198 8.864 22.925 FALSE
GLR2 MTG6 -2.562 11.500 25.562 FALSE
GLR2 RK1 -1.698 12.364 26.425 FALSE
GLR2 SS -1.516 12.546 26.607 FALSE
GLR2 TTOS -0.380 13.682 27.744 FALSE
GLR2 VA1 0.302 14.364 28.425 TRUE
GLR2 VA2 -0.153 13.909 27.971 FALSE
GLR2 XLZZG -0.062 14.000 28.062 FALSE
GLR2 XZZ 2.075 16.136 30.198 TRUE
GP GT1 -14.153 -0.091 13.971 FALSE
GP GT2 -14.471 -0.409 13.653 FALSE
GP HNOS1 -14.380 -0.318 13.743 FALSE
GP HNOS2 -14.380 -0.318 13.743 FALSE
GP HNOS3 -12.743 1.318 15.380 FALSE
GP HNOS4 -12.471 1.591 15.653 FALSE
GP HW1 -12.698 1.364 15.425 FALSE
GP HW2 -10.516 3.546 17.607 FALSE
GP LZG -9.834 4.227 18.289 FALSE
GP MTG1 -8.516 5.545 19.607 FALSE
GP MTG2 -7.516 6.545 20.607 FALSE
GP MTG3 -9.243 4.818 18.880 FALSE
GP MTG4 -6.653 7.409 21.471 FALSE
GP MTG5 -6.289 7.773 21.834 FALSE
GP MTG6 -3.653 10.409 24.471 FALSE
GP RK1 -2.789 11.273 25.334 FALSE
GP SS -2.607 11.454 25.516 FALSE
GP TTOS -1.471 12.591 26.653 FALSE
GP VA1 -0.789 13.273 27.334 FALSE
GP VA2 -1.244 12.818 26.880 FALSE
GP XLZZG -1.153 12.909 26.971 FALSE
GP XZZ 0.984 15.046 29.107 TRUE
GT1 GT2 -14.380 -0.318 13.743 FALSE
GT1 HNOS1 -14.289 -0.227 13.834 FALSE
GT1 HNOS2 -14.289 -0.227 13.834 FALSE
GT1 HNOS3 -12.653 1.409 15.471 FALSE
GT1 HNOS4 -12.380 1.682 15.743 FALSE
GT1 HW1 -12.607 1.454 15.516 FALSE
GT1 HW2 -10.425 3.636 17.698 FALSE
GT1 LZG -9.743 4.318 18.380 FALSE
GT1 MTG1 -8.425 5.636 19.698 FALSE
GT1 MTG2 -7.425 6.636 20.698 FALSE
GT1 MTG3 -9.153 4.909 18.971 FALSE
GT1 MTG4 -6.562 7.500 21.562 FALSE
GT1 MTG5 -6.198 7.864 21.925 FALSE
GT1 MTG6 -3.562 10.500 24.562 FALSE
GT1 RK1 -2.698 11.364 25.425 FALSE
GT1 SS -2.516 11.546 25.607 FALSE
GT1 TTOS -1.380 12.682 26.744 FALSE
GT1 VA1 -0.698 13.364 27.425 FALSE
GT1 VA2 -1.153 12.909 26.971 FALSE
GT1 XLZZG -1.062 13.000 27.062 FALSE
GT1 XZZ 1.075 15.136 29.198 TRUE
GT2 HNOS1 -13.971 0.091 14.153 FALSE
GT2 HNOS2 -13.971 0.091 14.153 FALSE
GT2 HNOS3 -12.334 1.727 15.789 FALSE
GT2 HNOS4 -12.062 2.000 16.062 FALSE
GT2 HW1 -12.289 1.773 15.834 FALSE
GT2 HW2 -10.107 3.954 18.016 FALSE
GT2 LZG -9.425 4.636 18.698 FALSE
GT2 MTG1 -8.107 5.955 20.016 FALSE
GT2 MTG2 -7.107 6.955 21.016 FALSE
GT2 MTG3 -8.834 5.227 19.289 FALSE
GT2 MTG4 -6.244 7.818 21.880 FALSE
GT2 MTG5 -5.880 8.182 22.244 FALSE
GT2 MTG6 -3.244 10.818 24.880 FALSE
GT2 RK1 -2.380 11.682 25.744 FALSE
GT2 SS -2.198 11.864 25.925 FALSE
GT2 TTOS -1.062 13.000 27.062 FALSE
GT2 VA1 -0.380 13.682 27.744 FALSE
GT2 VA2 -0.834 13.227 27.289 FALSE
GT2 XLZZG -0.744 13.318 27.380 FALSE
GT2 XZZ 1.393 15.454 29.516 TRUE
HNOS1 HNOS2 -14.062 0.000 14.062 FALSE
HNOS1 HNOS3 -12.425 1.636 15.698 FALSE
HNOS1 HNOS4 -12.153 1.909 15.971 FALSE
HNOS1 HW1 -12.380 1.682 15.743 FALSE
HNOS1 HW2 -10.198 3.864 17.925 FALSE
HNOS1 LZG -9.516 4.545 18.607 FALSE
HNOS1 MTG1 -8.198 5.864 19.925 FALSE
HNOS1 MTG2 -7.198 6.864 20.925 FALSE
HNOS1 MTG3 -8.925 5.136 19.198 FALSE
HNOS1 MTG4 -6.334 7.727 21.789 FALSE
HNOS1 MTG5 -5.971 8.091 22.153 FALSE
HNOS1 MTG6 -3.334 10.727 24.789 FALSE
HNOS1 RK1 -2.471 11.591 25.653 FALSE
HNOS1 SS -2.289 11.773 25.834 FALSE
HNOS1 TTOS -1.153 12.909 26.971 FALSE
HNOS1 VA1 -0.471 13.591 27.653 FALSE
HNOS1 VA2 -0.925 13.136 27.198 FALSE
HNOS1 XLZZG -0.834 13.227 27.289 FALSE
HNOS1 XZZ 1.302 15.364 29.425 TRUE
HNOS2 HNOS3 -12.425 1.636 15.698 FALSE
HNOS2 HNOS4 -12.153 1.909 15.971 FALSE
HNOS2 HW1 -12.380 1.682 15.743 FALSE
HNOS2 HW2 -10.198 3.864 17.925 FALSE
HNOS2 LZG -9.516 4.545 18.607 FALSE
HNOS2 MTG1 -8.198 5.864 19.925 FALSE
HNOS2 MTG2 -7.198 6.864 20.925 FALSE
HNOS2 MTG3 -8.925 5.136 19.198 FALSE
HNOS2 MTG4 -6.334 7.727 21.789 FALSE
HNOS2 MTG5 -5.971 8.091 22.153 FALSE
HNOS2 MTG6 -3.334 10.727 24.789 FALSE
HNOS2 RK1 -2.471 11.591 25.653 FALSE
HNOS2 SS -2.289 11.773 25.834 FALSE
HNOS2 TTOS -1.153 12.909 26.971 FALSE
HNOS2 VA1 -0.471 13.591 27.653 FALSE
HNOS2 VA2 -0.925 13.136 27.198 FALSE
HNOS2 XLZZG -0.834 13.227 27.289 FALSE
HNOS2 XZZ 1.302 15.364 29.425 TRUE
HNOS3 HNOS4 -13.789 0.273 14.334 FALSE
HNOS3 HW1 -14.016 0.045 14.107 FALSE
HNOS3 HW2 -11.834 2.227 16.289 FALSE
HNOS3 LZG -11.153 2.909 16.971 FALSE
HNOS3 MTG1 -9.834 4.227 18.289 FALSE
HNOS3 MTG2 -8.834 5.227 19.289 FALSE
HNOS3 MTG3 -10.562 3.500 17.562 FALSE
HNOS3 MTG4 -7.971 6.091 20.153 FALSE
HNOS3 MTG5 -7.607 6.455 20.516 FALSE
HNOS3 MTG6 -4.971 9.091 23.153 FALSE
HNOS3 RK1 -4.107 9.954 24.016 FALSE
HNOS3 SS -3.925 10.136 24.198 FALSE
HNOS3 TTOS -2.789 11.273 25.334 FALSE
HNOS3 VA1 -2.107 11.954 26.016 FALSE
HNOS3 VA2 -2.562 11.500 25.562 FALSE
HNOS3 XLZZG -2.471 11.591 25.653 FALSE
HNOS3 XZZ -0.334 13.727 27.789 FALSE
HNOS4 HW1 -14.289 -0.227 13.834 FALSE
HNOS4 HW2 -12.107 1.954 16.016 FALSE
HNOS4 LZG -11.425 2.636 16.698 FALSE
HNOS4 MTG1 -10.107 3.954 18.016 FALSE
HNOS4 MTG2 -9.107 4.955 19.016 FALSE
HNOS4 MTG3 -10.834 3.227 17.289 FALSE
HNOS4 MTG4 -8.243 5.818 19.880 FALSE
HNOS4 MTG5 -7.880 6.182 20.244 FALSE
HNOS4 MTG6 -5.244 8.818 22.880 FALSE
HNOS4 RK1 -4.380 9.682 23.744 FALSE
HNOS4 SS -4.198 9.864 23.925 FALSE
HNOS4 TTOS -3.062 11.000 25.062 FALSE
HNOS4 VA1 -2.380 11.682 25.744 FALSE
HNOS4 VA2 -2.834 11.227 25.289 FALSE
HNOS4 XLZZG -2.744 11.318 25.380 FALSE
HNOS4 XZZ -0.607 13.454 27.516 FALSE
HW1 HW2 -11.880 2.182 16.244 FALSE
HW1 LZG -11.198 2.864 16.925 FALSE
HW1 MTG1 -9.880 4.182 18.244 FALSE
HW1 MTG2 -8.880 5.182 19.244 FALSE
HW1 MTG3 -10.607 3.454 17.516 FALSE
HW1 MTG4 -8.016 6.045 20.107 FALSE
HW1 MTG5 -7.653 6.409 20.471 FALSE
HW1 MTG6 -5.016 9.046 23.107 FALSE
HW1 RK1 -4.153 9.909 23.971 FALSE
HW1 SS -3.971 10.091 24.153 FALSE
HW1 TTOS -2.834 11.227 25.289 FALSE
HW1 VA1 -2.153 11.909 25.971 FALSE
HW1 VA2 -2.607 11.454 25.516 FALSE
HW1 XLZZG -2.516 11.546 25.607 FALSE
HW1 XZZ -0.380 13.682 27.744 FALSE
HW2 LZG -13.380 0.682 14.743 FALSE
HW2 MTG1 -12.062 2.000 16.062 FALSE
HW2 MTG2 -11.062 3.000 17.062 FALSE
HW2 MTG3 -12.789 1.273 15.334 FALSE
HW2 MTG4 -10.198 3.864 17.925 FALSE
HW2 MTG5 -9.834 4.227 18.289 FALSE
HW2 MTG6 -7.198 6.864 20.925 FALSE
HW2 RK1 -6.334 7.727 21.789 FALSE
HW2 SS -6.153 7.909 21.971 FALSE
HW2 TTOS -5.016 9.046 23.107 FALSE
HW2 VA1 -4.334 9.727 23.789 FALSE
HW2 VA2 -4.789 9.273 23.334 FALSE
HW2 XLZZG -4.698 9.364 23.425 FALSE
HW2 XZZ -2.562 11.500 25.562 FALSE
LZG MTG1 -12.743 1.318 15.380 FALSE
LZG MTG2 -11.743 2.318 16.380 FALSE
LZG MTG3 -13.471 0.591 14.653 FALSE
LZG MTG4 -10.880 3.182 17.244 FALSE
LZG MTG5 -10.516 3.546 17.607 FALSE
LZG MTG6 -7.880 6.182 20.244 FALSE
LZG RK1 -7.016 7.045 21.107 FALSE
LZG SS -6.834 7.227 21.289 FALSE
LZG TTOS -5.698 8.364 22.425 FALSE
LZG VA1 -5.016 9.046 23.107 FALSE
LZG VA2 -5.471 8.591 22.653 FALSE
LZG XLZZG -5.380 8.682 22.744 FALSE
LZG XZZ -3.244 10.818 24.880 FALSE
MTG1 MTG2 -13.062 1.000 15.062 FALSE
MTG1 MTG3 -14.789 -0.727 13.334 FALSE
MTG1 MTG4 -12.198 1.864 15.925 FALSE
MTG1 MTG5 -11.834 2.227 16.289 FALSE
MTG1 MTG6 -9.198 4.864 18.925 FALSE
MTG1 RK1 -8.334 5.727 19.789 FALSE
MTG1 SS -8.153 5.909 19.971 FALSE
MTG1 TTOS -7.016 7.045 21.107 FALSE
MTG1 VA1 -6.334 7.727 21.789 FALSE
MTG1 VA2 -6.789 7.273 21.334 FALSE
MTG1 XLZZG -6.698 7.364 21.425 FALSE
MTG1 XZZ -4.562 9.500 23.562 FALSE
MTG2 MTG3 -15.789 -1.727 12.334 FALSE
MTG2 MTG4 -13.198 0.864 14.925 FALSE
MTG2 MTG5 -12.834 1.227 15.289 FALSE
MTG2 MTG6 -10.198 3.864 17.925 FALSE
MTG2 RK1 -9.334 4.727 18.789 FALSE
MTG2 SS -9.153 4.909 18.971 FALSE
MTG2 TTOS -8.016 6.045 20.107 FALSE
MTG2 VA1 -7.334 6.727 20.789 FALSE
MTG2 VA2 -7.789 6.273 20.334 FALSE
MTG2 XLZZG -7.698 6.364 20.425 FALSE
MTG2 XZZ -5.562 8.500 22.562 FALSE
MTG3 MTG4 -11.471 2.591 16.653 FALSE
MTG3 MTG5 -11.107 2.954 17.016 FALSE
MTG3 MTG6 -8.471 5.591 19.653 FALSE
MTG3 RK1 -7.607 6.455 20.516 FALSE
MTG3 SS -7.425 6.636 20.698 FALSE
MTG3 TTOS -6.289 7.773 21.834 FALSE
MTG3 VA1 -5.607 8.454 22.516 FALSE
MTG3 VA2 -6.062 8.000 22.062 FALSE
MTG3 XLZZG -5.971 8.091 22.153 FALSE
MTG3 XZZ -3.834 10.227 24.289 FALSE
MTG4 MTG5 -13.698 0.364 14.425 FALSE
MTG4 MTG6 -11.062 3.000 17.062 FALSE
MTG4 RK1 -10.198 3.864 17.925 FALSE
MTG4 SS -10.016 4.045 18.107 FALSE
MTG4 TTOS -8.880 5.182 19.244 FALSE
MTG4 VA1 -8.198 5.864 19.925 FALSE
MTG4 VA2 -8.653 5.409 19.471 FALSE
MTG4 XLZZG -8.562 5.500 19.562 FALSE
MTG4 XZZ -6.425 7.636 21.698 FALSE
MTG5 MTG6 -11.425 2.636 16.698 FALSE
MTG5 RK1 -10.562 3.500 17.562 FALSE
MTG5 SS -10.380 3.682 17.744 FALSE
MTG5 TTOS -9.243 4.818 18.880 FALSE
MTG5 VA1 -8.562 5.500 19.562 FALSE
MTG5 VA2 -9.016 5.045 19.107 FALSE
MTG5 XLZZG -8.925 5.136 19.198 FALSE
MTG5 XZZ -6.789 7.273 21.334 FALSE
MTG6 RK1 -13.198 0.864 14.925 FALSE
MTG6 SS -13.016 1.046 15.107 FALSE
MTG6 TTOS -11.880 2.182 16.244 FALSE
MTG6 VA1 -11.198 2.864 16.925 FALSE
MTG6 VA2 -11.653 2.409 16.471 FALSE
MTG6 XLZZG -11.562 2.500 16.562 FALSE
MTG6 XZZ -9.425 4.636 18.698 FALSE
RK1 SS -13.880 0.182 14.243 FALSE
RK1 TTOS -12.743 1.318 15.380 FALSE
RK1 VA1 -12.062 2.000 16.062 FALSE
RK1 VA2 -12.516 1.546 15.607 FALSE
RK1 XLZZG -12.425 1.636 15.698 FALSE
RK1 XZZ -10.289 3.773 17.834 FALSE
SS TTOS -12.925 1.136 15.198 FALSE
SS VA1 -12.243 1.818 15.880 FALSE
SS VA2 -12.698 1.364 15.425 FALSE
SS XLZZG -12.607 1.454 15.516 FALSE
SS XZZ -10.471 3.591 17.653 FALSE
TTOS VA1 -13.380 0.682 14.743 FALSE
TTOS VA2 -13.834 0.227 14.289 FALSE
TTOS XLZZG -13.743 0.318 14.380 FALSE
TTOS XZZ -11.607 2.454 16.516 FALSE
VA1 VA2 -14.516 -0.455 13.607 FALSE
VA1 XLZZG -14.425 -0.364 13.698 FALSE
VA1 XZZ -12.289 1.773 15.834 FALSE
VA2 XLZZG -13.971 0.091 14.153 FALSE
VA2 XZZ -11.834 2.227 16.289 FALSE
XLZZG XZZ -11.925 2.136 16.198 FALSE

download these results as csv

https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiocomposer/small.audiocomposer_Accuracy_Per_Class.friedman.tukeyKramerHSD.png

Folds vs. Systems Tukey-Kramer HSD Multi-Comparison

The Friedman test was run in MATLAB against the accuracy for each fold. The Tukey-Kramer HSD multi-comparison data below was generated using the following MATLAB instruction. Command:
[c, m, h, gnames] = multicompare(stats, 'ctype', 'tukey-kramer', 'estimate', 'friedman', 'alpha', 0.05);

TeamID TeamID Lowerbound Mean Upperbound Significance
ANO BP1 -26.595 0.333 27.262 FALSE
ANO BP2 -25.262 1.667 28.595 FALSE
ANO CL1 -23.262 3.667 30.595 FALSE
ANO CL2 -22.762 4.167 31.095 FALSE
ANO GLR1 -20.929 6.000 32.929 FALSE
ANO GLR2 -19.595 7.333 34.262 FALSE
ANO GP -19.095 7.833 34.762 FALSE
ANO GT1 -19.262 7.667 34.595 FALSE
ANO GT2 -18.595 8.333 35.262 FALSE
ANO HNOS1 -17.262 9.667 36.595 FALSE
ANO HNOS2 -17.262 9.667 36.595 FALSE
ANO HNOS3 -17.262 9.667 36.595 FALSE
ANO HNOS4 -15.595 11.333 38.262 FALSE
ANO HW1 -13.929 13.000 39.929 FALSE
ANO HW2 -12.262 14.667 41.595 FALSE
ANO LZG -11.595 15.333 42.262 FALSE
ANO MTG1 -9.929 17.000 43.929 FALSE
ANO MTG2 -8.929 18.000 44.929 FALSE
ANO MTG3 -7.929 19.000 45.929 FALSE
ANO MTG4 -7.262 19.667 46.595 FALSE
ANO MTG5 -7.262 19.667 46.595 FALSE
ANO MTG6 -5.095 21.833 48.762 FALSE
ANO RK1 -3.429 23.500 50.429 FALSE
ANO SS -2.929 24.000 50.929 FALSE
ANO TTOS -2.262 24.667 51.595 FALSE
ANO VA1 -1.262 25.667 52.595 FALSE
ANO VA2 -1.595 25.333 52.262 FALSE
ANO XLZZG 0.738 27.667 54.595 TRUE
ANO XZZ 1.738 28.667 55.595 TRUE
BP1 BP2 -25.595 1.333 28.262 FALSE
BP1 CL1 -23.595 3.333 30.262 FALSE
BP1 CL2 -23.095 3.833 30.762 FALSE
BP1 GLR1 -21.262 5.667 32.595 FALSE
BP1 GLR2 -19.929 7.000 33.929 FALSE
BP1 GP -19.429 7.500 34.429 FALSE
BP1 GT1 -19.595 7.333 34.262 FALSE
BP1 GT2 -18.929 8.000 34.929 FALSE
BP1 HNOS1 -17.595 9.333 36.262 FALSE
BP1 HNOS2 -17.595 9.333 36.262 FALSE
BP1 HNOS3 -17.595 9.333 36.262 FALSE
BP1 HNOS4 -15.929 11.000 37.929 FALSE
BP1 HW1 -14.262 12.667 39.595 FALSE
BP1 HW2 -12.595 14.333 41.262 FALSE
BP1 LZG -11.929 15.000 41.929 FALSE
BP1 MTG1 -10.262 16.667 43.595 FALSE
BP1 MTG2 -9.262 17.667 44.595 FALSE
BP1 MTG3 -8.262 18.667 45.595 FALSE
BP1 MTG4 -7.595 19.333 46.262 FALSE
BP1 MTG5 -7.595 19.333 46.262 FALSE
BP1 MTG6 -5.429 21.500 48.429 FALSE
BP1 RK1 -3.762 23.167 50.095 FALSE
BP1 SS -3.262 23.667 50.595 FALSE
BP1 TTOS -2.595 24.333 51.262 FALSE
BP1 VA1 -1.595 25.333 52.262 FALSE
BP1 VA2 -1.929 25.000 51.929 FALSE
BP1 XLZZG 0.405 27.333 54.262 TRUE
BP1 XZZ 1.405 28.333 55.262 TRUE
BP2 CL1 -24.929 2.000 28.929 FALSE
BP2 CL2 -24.429 2.500 29.429 FALSE
BP2 GLR1 -22.595 4.333 31.262 FALSE
BP2 GLR2 -21.262 5.667 32.595 FALSE
BP2 GP -20.762 6.167 33.095 FALSE
BP2 GT1 -20.929 6.000 32.929 FALSE
BP2 GT2 -20.262 6.667 33.595 FALSE
BP2 HNOS1 -18.929 8.000 34.929 FALSE
BP2 HNOS2 -18.929 8.000 34.929 FALSE
BP2 HNOS3 -18.929 8.000 34.929 FALSE
BP2 HNOS4 -17.262 9.667 36.595 FALSE
BP2 HW1 -15.595 11.333 38.262 FALSE
BP2 HW2 -13.929 13.000 39.929 FALSE
BP2 LZG -13.262 13.667 40.595 FALSE
BP2 MTG1 -11.595 15.333 42.262 FALSE
BP2 MTG2 -10.595 16.333 43.262 FALSE
BP2 MTG3 -9.595 17.333 44.262 FALSE
BP2 MTG4 -8.929 18.000 44.929 FALSE
BP2 MTG5 -8.929 18.000 44.929 FALSE
BP2 MTG6 -6.762 20.167 47.095 FALSE
BP2 RK1 -5.095 21.833 48.762 FALSE
BP2 SS -4.595 22.333 49.262 FALSE
BP2 TTOS -3.929 23.000 49.929 FALSE
BP2 VA1 -2.929 24.000 50.929 FALSE
BP2 VA2 -3.262 23.667 50.595 FALSE
BP2 XLZZG -0.929 26.000 52.929 FALSE
BP2 XZZ 0.071 27.000 53.929 TRUE
CL1 CL2 -26.429 0.500 27.429 FALSE
CL1 GLR1 -24.595 2.333 29.262 FALSE
CL1 GLR2 -23.262 3.667 30.595 FALSE
CL1 GP -22.762 4.167 31.095 FALSE
CL1 GT1 -22.929 4.000 30.929 FALSE
CL1 GT2 -22.262 4.667 31.595 FALSE
CL1 HNOS1 -20.929 6.000 32.929 FALSE
CL1 HNOS2 -20.929 6.000 32.929 FALSE
CL1 HNOS3 -20.929 6.000 32.929 FALSE
CL1 HNOS4 -19.262 7.667 34.595 FALSE
CL1 HW1 -17.595 9.333 36.262 FALSE
CL1 HW2 -15.929 11.000 37.929 FALSE
CL1 LZG -15.262 11.667 38.595 FALSE
CL1 MTG1 -13.595 13.333 40.262 FALSE
CL1 MTG2 -12.595 14.333 41.262 FALSE
CL1 MTG3 -11.595 15.333 42.262 FALSE
CL1 MTG4 -10.929 16.000 42.929 FALSE
CL1 MTG5 -10.929 16.000 42.929 FALSE
CL1 MTG6 -8.762 18.167 45.095 FALSE
CL1 RK1 -7.095 19.833 46.762 FALSE
CL1 SS -6.595 20.333 47.262 FALSE
CL1 TTOS -5.929 21.000 47.929 FALSE
CL1 VA1 -4.929 22.000 48.929 FALSE
CL1 VA2 -5.262 21.667 48.595 FALSE
CL1 XLZZG -2.929 24.000 50.929 FALSE
CL1 XZZ -1.929 25.000 51.929 FALSE
CL2 GLR1 -25.095 1.833 28.762 FALSE
CL2 GLR2 -23.762 3.167 30.095 FALSE
CL2 GP -23.262 3.667 30.595 FALSE
CL2 GT1 -23.429 3.500 30.429 FALSE
CL2 GT2 -22.762 4.167 31.095 FALSE
CL2 HNOS1 -21.429 5.500 32.429 FALSE
CL2 HNOS2 -21.429 5.500 32.429 FALSE
CL2 HNOS3 -21.429 5.500 32.429 FALSE
CL2 HNOS4 -19.762 7.167 34.095 FALSE
CL2 HW1 -18.095 8.833 35.762 FALSE
CL2 HW2 -16.429 10.500 37.429 FALSE
CL2 LZG -15.762 11.167 38.095 FALSE
CL2 MTG1 -14.095 12.833 39.762 FALSE
CL2 MTG2 -13.095 13.833 40.762 FALSE
CL2 MTG3 -12.095 14.833 41.762 FALSE
CL2 MTG4 -11.429 15.500 42.429 FALSE
CL2 MTG5 -11.429 15.500 42.429 FALSE
CL2 MTG6 -9.262 17.667 44.595 FALSE
CL2 RK1 -7.595 19.333 46.262 FALSE
CL2 SS -7.095 19.833 46.762 FALSE
CL2 TTOS -6.429 20.500 47.429 FALSE
CL2 VA1 -5.429 21.500 48.429 FALSE
CL2 VA2 -5.762 21.167 48.095 FALSE
CL2 XLZZG -3.429 23.500 50.429 FALSE
CL2 XZZ -2.429 24.500 51.429 FALSE
GLR1 GLR2 -25.595 1.333 28.262 FALSE
GLR1 GP -25.095 1.833 28.762 FALSE
GLR1 GT1 -25.262 1.667 28.595 FALSE
GLR1 GT2 -24.595 2.333 29.262 FALSE
GLR1 HNOS1 -23.262 3.667 30.595 FALSE
GLR1 HNOS2 -23.262 3.667 30.595 FALSE
GLR1 HNOS3 -23.262 3.667 30.595 FALSE
GLR1 HNOS4 -21.595 5.333 32.262 FALSE
GLR1 HW1 -19.929 7.000 33.929 FALSE
GLR1 HW2 -18.262 8.667 35.595 FALSE
GLR1 LZG -17.595 9.333 36.262 FALSE
GLR1 MTG1 -15.929 11.000 37.929 FALSE
GLR1 MTG2 -14.929 12.000 38.929 FALSE
GLR1 MTG3 -13.929 13.000 39.929 FALSE
GLR1 MTG4 -13.262 13.667 40.595 FALSE
GLR1 MTG5 -13.262 13.667 40.595 FALSE
GLR1 MTG6 -11.095 15.833 42.762 FALSE
GLR1 RK1 -9.429 17.500 44.429 FALSE
GLR1 SS -8.929 18.000 44.929 FALSE
GLR1 TTOS -8.262 18.667 45.595 FALSE
GLR1 VA1 -7.262 19.667 46.595 FALSE
GLR1 VA2 -7.595 19.333 46.262 FALSE
GLR1 XLZZG -5.262 21.667 48.595 FALSE
GLR1 XZZ -4.262 22.667 49.595 FALSE
GLR2 GP -26.429 0.500 27.429 FALSE
GLR2 GT1 -26.595 0.333 27.262 FALSE
GLR2 GT2 -25.929 1.000 27.929 FALSE
GLR2 HNOS1 -24.595 2.333 29.262 FALSE
GLR2 HNOS2 -24.595 2.333 29.262 FALSE
GLR2 HNOS3 -24.595 2.333 29.262 FALSE
GLR2 HNOS4 -22.929 4.000 30.929 FALSE
GLR2 HW1 -21.262 5.667 32.595 FALSE
GLR2 HW2 -19.595 7.333 34.262 FALSE
GLR2 LZG -18.929 8.000 34.929 FALSE
GLR2 MTG1 -17.262 9.667 36.595 FALSE
GLR2 MTG2 -16.262 10.667 37.595 FALSE
GLR2 MTG3 -15.262 11.667 38.595 FALSE
GLR2 MTG4 -14.595 12.333 39.262 FALSE
GLR2 MTG5 -14.595 12.333 39.262 FALSE
GLR2 MTG6 -12.429 14.500 41.429 FALSE
GLR2 RK1 -10.762 16.167 43.095 FALSE
GLR2 SS -10.262 16.667 43.595 FALSE
GLR2 TTOS -9.595 17.333 44.262 FALSE
GLR2 VA1 -8.595 18.333 45.262 FALSE
GLR2 VA2 -8.929 18.000 44.929 FALSE
GLR2 XLZZG -6.595 20.333 47.262 FALSE
GLR2 XZZ -5.595 21.333 48.262 FALSE
GP GT1 -27.095 -0.167 26.762 FALSE
GP GT2 -26.429 0.500 27.429 FALSE
GP HNOS1 -25.095 1.833 28.762 FALSE
GP HNOS2 -25.095 1.833 28.762 FALSE
GP HNOS3 -25.095 1.833 28.762 FALSE
GP HNOS4 -23.429 3.500 30.429 FALSE
GP HW1 -21.762 5.167 32.095 FALSE
GP HW2 -20.095 6.833 33.762 FALSE
GP LZG -19.429 7.500 34.429 FALSE
GP MTG1 -17.762 9.167 36.095 FALSE
GP MTG2 -16.762 10.167 37.095 FALSE
GP MTG3 -15.762 11.167 38.095 FALSE
GP MTG4 -15.095 11.833 38.762 FALSE
GP MTG5 -15.095 11.833 38.762 FALSE
GP MTG6 -12.929 14.000 40.929 FALSE
GP RK1 -11.262 15.667 42.595 FALSE
GP SS -10.762 16.167 43.095 FALSE
GP TTOS -10.095 16.833 43.762 FALSE
GP VA1 -9.095 17.833 44.762 FALSE
GP VA2 -9.429 17.500 44.429 FALSE
GP XLZZG -7.095 19.833 46.762 FALSE
GP XZZ -6.095 20.833 47.762 FALSE
GT1 GT2 -26.262 0.667 27.595 FALSE
GT1 HNOS1 -24.929 2.000 28.929 FALSE
GT1 HNOS2 -24.929 2.000 28.929 FALSE
GT1 HNOS3 -24.929 2.000 28.929 FALSE
GT1 HNOS4 -23.262 3.667 30.595 FALSE
GT1 HW1 -21.595 5.333 32.262 FALSE
GT1 HW2 -19.929 7.000 33.929 FALSE
GT1 LZG -19.262 7.667 34.595 FALSE
GT1 MTG1 -17.595 9.333 36.262 FALSE
GT1 MTG2 -16.595 10.333 37.262 FALSE
GT1 MTG3 -15.595 11.333 38.262 FALSE
GT1 MTG4 -14.929 12.000 38.929 FALSE
GT1 MTG5 -14.929 12.000 38.929 FALSE
GT1 MTG6 -12.762 14.167 41.095 FALSE
GT1 RK1 -11.095 15.833 42.762 FALSE
GT1 SS -10.595 16.333 43.262 FALSE
GT1 TTOS -9.929 17.000 43.929 FALSE
GT1 VA1 -8.929 18.000 44.929 FALSE
GT1 VA2 -9.262 17.667 44.595 FALSE
GT1 XLZZG -6.929 20.000 46.929 FALSE
GT1 XZZ -5.929 21.000 47.929 FALSE
GT2 HNOS1 -25.595 1.333 28.262 FALSE
GT2 HNOS2 -25.595 1.333 28.262 FALSE
GT2 HNOS3 -25.595 1.333 28.262 FALSE
GT2 HNOS4 -23.929 3.000 29.929 FALSE
GT2 HW1 -22.262 4.667 31.595 FALSE
GT2 HW2 -20.595 6.333 33.262 FALSE
GT2 LZG -19.929 7.000 33.929 FALSE
GT2 MTG1 -18.262 8.667 35.595 FALSE
GT2 MTG2 -17.262 9.667 36.595 FALSE
GT2 MTG3 -16.262 10.667 37.595 FALSE
GT2 MTG4 -15.595 11.333 38.262 FALSE
GT2 MTG5 -15.595 11.333 38.262 FALSE
GT2 MTG6 -13.429 13.500 40.429 FALSE
GT2 RK1 -11.762 15.167 42.095 FALSE
GT2 SS -11.262 15.667 42.595 FALSE
GT2 TTOS -10.595 16.333 43.262 FALSE
GT2 VA1 -9.595 17.333 44.262 FALSE
GT2 VA2 -9.929 17.000 43.929 FALSE
GT2 XLZZG -7.595 19.333 46.262 FALSE
GT2 XZZ -6.595 20.333 47.262 FALSE
HNOS1 HNOS2 -26.929 0.000 26.929 FALSE
HNOS1 HNOS3 -26.929 0.000 26.929 FALSE
HNOS1 HNOS4 -25.262 1.667 28.595 FALSE
HNOS1 HW1 -23.595 3.333 30.262 FALSE
HNOS1 HW2 -21.929 5.000 31.929 FALSE
HNOS1 LZG -21.262 5.667 32.595 FALSE
HNOS1 MTG1 -19.595 7.333 34.262 FALSE
HNOS1 MTG2 -18.595 8.333 35.262 FALSE
HNOS1 MTG3 -17.595 9.333 36.262 FALSE
HNOS1 MTG4 -16.929 10.000 36.929 FALSE
HNOS1 MTG5 -16.929 10.000 36.929 FALSE
HNOS1 MTG6 -14.762 12.167 39.095 FALSE
HNOS1 RK1 -13.095 13.833 40.762 FALSE
HNOS1 SS -12.595 14.333 41.262 FALSE
HNOS1 TTOS -11.929 15.000 41.929 FALSE
HNOS1 VA1 -10.929 16.000 42.929 FALSE
HNOS1 VA2 -11.262 15.667 42.595 FALSE
HNOS1 XLZZG -8.929 18.000 44.929 FALSE
HNOS1 XZZ -7.929 19.000 45.929 FALSE
HNOS2 HNOS3 -26.929 0.000 26.929 FALSE
HNOS2 HNOS4 -25.262 1.667 28.595 FALSE
HNOS2 HW1 -23.595 3.333 30.262 FALSE
HNOS2 HW2 -21.929 5.000 31.929 FALSE
HNOS2 LZG -21.262 5.667 32.595 FALSE
HNOS2 MTG1 -19.595 7.333 34.262 FALSE
HNOS2 MTG2 -18.595 8.333 35.262 FALSE
HNOS2 MTG3 -17.595 9.333 36.262 FALSE
HNOS2 MTG4 -16.929 10.000 36.929 FALSE
HNOS2 MTG5 -16.929 10.000 36.929 FALSE
HNOS2 MTG6 -14.762 12.167 39.095 FALSE
HNOS2 RK1 -13.095 13.833 40.762 FALSE
HNOS2 SS -12.595 14.333 41.262 FALSE
HNOS2 TTOS -11.929 15.000 41.929 FALSE
HNOS2 VA1 -10.929 16.000 42.929 FALSE
HNOS2 VA2 -11.262 15.667 42.595 FALSE
HNOS2 XLZZG -8.929 18.000 44.929 FALSE
HNOS2 XZZ -7.929 19.000 45.929 FALSE
HNOS3 HNOS4 -25.262 1.667 28.595 FALSE
HNOS3 HW1 -23.595 3.333 30.262 FALSE
HNOS3 HW2 -21.929 5.000 31.929 FALSE
HNOS3 LZG -21.262 5.667 32.595 FALSE
HNOS3 MTG1 -19.595 7.333 34.262 FALSE
HNOS3 MTG2 -18.595 8.333 35.262 FALSE
HNOS3 MTG3 -17.595 9.333 36.262 FALSE
HNOS3 MTG4 -16.929 10.000 36.929 FALSE
HNOS3 MTG5 -16.929 10.000 36.929 FALSE
HNOS3 MTG6 -14.762 12.167 39.095 FALSE
HNOS3 RK1 -13.095 13.833 40.762 FALSE
HNOS3 SS -12.595 14.333 41.262 FALSE
HNOS3 TTOS -11.929 15.000 41.929 FALSE
HNOS3 VA1 -10.929 16.000 42.929 FALSE
HNOS3 VA2 -11.262 15.667 42.595 FALSE
HNOS3 XLZZG -8.929 18.000 44.929 FALSE
HNOS3 XZZ -7.929 19.000 45.929 FALSE
HNOS4 HW1 -25.262 1.667 28.595 FALSE
HNOS4 HW2 -23.595 3.333 30.262 FALSE
HNOS4 LZG -22.929 4.000 30.929 FALSE
HNOS4 MTG1 -21.262 5.667 32.595 FALSE
HNOS4 MTG2 -20.262 6.667 33.595 FALSE
HNOS4 MTG3 -19.262 7.667 34.595 FALSE
HNOS4 MTG4 -18.595 8.333 35.262 FALSE
HNOS4 MTG5 -18.595 8.333 35.262 FALSE
HNOS4 MTG6 -16.429 10.500 37.429 FALSE
HNOS4 RK1 -14.762 12.167 39.095 FALSE
HNOS4 SS -14.262 12.667 39.595 FALSE
HNOS4 TTOS -13.595 13.333 40.262 FALSE
HNOS4 VA1 -12.595 14.333 41.262 FALSE
HNOS4 VA2 -12.929 14.000 40.929 FALSE
HNOS4 XLZZG -10.595 16.333 43.262 FALSE
HNOS4 XZZ -9.595 17.333 44.262 FALSE
HW1 HW2 -25.262 1.667 28.595 FALSE
HW1 LZG -24.595 2.333 29.262 FALSE
HW1 MTG1 -22.929 4.000 30.929 FALSE
HW1 MTG2 -21.929 5.000 31.929 FALSE
HW1 MTG3 -20.929 6.000 32.929 FALSE
HW1 MTG4 -20.262 6.667 33.595 FALSE
HW1 MTG5 -20.262 6.667 33.595 FALSE
HW1 MTG6 -18.095 8.833 35.762 FALSE
HW1 RK1 -16.429 10.500 37.429 FALSE
HW1 SS -15.929 11.000 37.929 FALSE
HW1 TTOS -15.262 11.667 38.595 FALSE
HW1 VA1 -14.262 12.667 39.595 FALSE
HW1 VA2 -14.595 12.333 39.262 FALSE
HW1 XLZZG -12.262 14.667 41.595 FALSE
HW1 XZZ -11.262 15.667 42.595 FALSE
HW2 LZG -26.262 0.667 27.595 FALSE
HW2 MTG1 -24.595 2.333 29.262 FALSE
HW2 MTG2 -23.595 3.333 30.262 FALSE
HW2 MTG3 -22.595 4.333 31.262 FALSE
HW2 MTG4 -21.929 5.000 31.929 FALSE
HW2 MTG5 -21.929 5.000 31.929 FALSE
HW2 MTG6 -19.762 7.167 34.095 FALSE
HW2 RK1 -18.095 8.833 35.762 FALSE
HW2 SS -17.595 9.333 36.262 FALSE
HW2 TTOS -16.929 10.000 36.929 FALSE
HW2 VA1 -15.929 11.000 37.929 FALSE
HW2 VA2 -16.262 10.667 37.595 FALSE
HW2 XLZZG -13.929 13.000 39.929 FALSE
HW2 XZZ -12.929 14.000 40.929 FALSE
LZG MTG1 -25.262 1.667 28.595 FALSE
LZG MTG2 -24.262 2.667 29.595 FALSE
LZG MTG3 -23.262 3.667 30.595 FALSE
LZG MTG4 -22.595 4.333 31.262 FALSE
LZG MTG5 -22.595 4.333 31.262 FALSE
LZG MTG6 -20.429 6.500 33.429 FALSE
LZG RK1 -18.762 8.167 35.095 FALSE
LZG SS -18.262 8.667 35.595 FALSE
LZG TTOS -17.595 9.333 36.262 FALSE
LZG VA1 -16.595 10.333 37.262 FALSE
LZG VA2 -16.929 10.000 36.929 FALSE
LZG XLZZG -14.595 12.333 39.262 FALSE
LZG XZZ -13.595 13.333 40.262 FALSE
MTG1 MTG2 -25.929 1.000 27.929 FALSE
MTG1 MTG3 -24.929 2.000 28.929 FALSE
MTG1 MTG4 -24.262 2.667 29.595 FALSE
MTG1 MTG5 -24.262 2.667 29.595 FALSE
MTG1 MTG6 -22.095 4.833 31.762 FALSE
MTG1 RK1 -20.429 6.500 33.429 FALSE
MTG1 SS -19.929 7.000 33.929 FALSE
MTG1 TTOS -19.262 7.667 34.595 FALSE
MTG1 VA1 -18.262 8.667 35.595 FALSE
MTG1 VA2 -18.595 8.333 35.262 FALSE
MTG1 XLZZG -16.262 10.667 37.595 FALSE
MTG1 XZZ -15.262 11.667 38.595 FALSE
MTG2 MTG3 -25.929 1.000 27.929 FALSE
MTG2 MTG4 -25.262 1.667 28.595 FALSE
MTG2 MTG5 -25.262 1.667 28.595 FALSE
MTG2 MTG6 -23.095 3.833 30.762 FALSE
MTG2 RK1 -21.429 5.500 32.429 FALSE
MTG2 SS -20.929 6.000 32.929 FALSE
MTG2 TTOS -20.262 6.667 33.595 FALSE
MTG2 VA1 -19.262 7.667 34.595 FALSE
MTG2 VA2 -19.595 7.333 34.262 FALSE
MTG2 XLZZG -17.262 9.667 36.595 FALSE
MTG2 XZZ -16.262 10.667 37.595 FALSE
MTG3 MTG4 -26.262 0.667 27.595 FALSE
MTG3 MTG5 -26.262 0.667 27.595 FALSE
MTG3 MTG6 -24.095 2.833 29.762 FALSE
MTG3 RK1 -22.429 4.500 31.429 FALSE
MTG3 SS -21.929 5.000 31.929 FALSE
MTG3 TTOS -21.262 5.667 32.595 FALSE
MTG3 VA1 -20.262 6.667 33.595 FALSE
MTG3 VA2 -20.595 6.333 33.262 FALSE
MTG3 XLZZG -18.262 8.667 35.595 FALSE
MTG3 XZZ -17.262 9.667 36.595 FALSE
MTG4 MTG5 -26.929 0.000 26.929 FALSE
MTG4 MTG6 -24.762 2.167 29.095 FALSE
MTG4 RK1 -23.095 3.833 30.762 FALSE
MTG4 SS -22.595 4.333 31.262 FALSE
MTG4 TTOS -21.929 5.000 31.929 FALSE
MTG4 VA1 -20.929 6.000 32.929 FALSE
MTG4 VA2 -21.262 5.667 32.595 FALSE
MTG4 XLZZG -18.929 8.000 34.929 FALSE
MTG4 XZZ -17.929 9.000 35.929 FALSE
MTG5 MTG6 -24.762 2.167 29.095 FALSE
MTG5 RK1 -23.095 3.833 30.762 FALSE
MTG5 SS -22.595 4.333 31.262 FALSE
MTG5 TTOS -21.929 5.000 31.929 FALSE
MTG5 VA1 -20.929 6.000 32.929 FALSE
MTG5 VA2 -21.262 5.667 32.595 FALSE
MTG5 XLZZG -18.929 8.000 34.929 FALSE
MTG5 XZZ -17.929 9.000 35.929 FALSE
MTG6 RK1 -25.262 1.667 28.595 FALSE
MTG6 SS -24.762 2.167 29.095 FALSE
MTG6 TTOS -24.095 2.833 29.762 FALSE
MTG6 VA1 -23.095 3.833 30.762 FALSE
MTG6 VA2 -23.429 3.500 30.429 FALSE
MTG6 XLZZG -21.095 5.833 32.762 FALSE
MTG6 XZZ -20.095 6.833 33.762 FALSE
RK1 SS -26.429 0.500 27.429 FALSE
RK1 TTOS -25.762 1.167 28.095 FALSE
RK1 VA1 -24.762 2.167 29.095 FALSE
RK1 VA2 -25.095 1.833 28.762 FALSE
RK1 XLZZG -22.762 4.167 31.095 FALSE
RK1 XZZ -21.762 5.167 32.095 FALSE
SS TTOS -26.262 0.667 27.595 FALSE
SS VA1 -25.262 1.667 28.595 FALSE
SS VA2 -25.595 1.333 28.262 FALSE
SS XLZZG -23.262 3.667 30.595 FALSE
SS XZZ -22.262 4.667 31.595 FALSE
TTOS VA1 -25.929 1.000 27.929 FALSE
TTOS VA2 -26.262 0.667 27.595 FALSE
TTOS XLZZG -23.929 3.000 29.929 FALSE
TTOS XZZ -22.929 4.000 30.929 FALSE
VA1 VA2 -27.262 -0.333 26.595 FALSE
VA1 XLZZG -24.929 2.000 28.929 FALSE
VA1 XZZ -23.929 3.000 29.929 FALSE
VA2 XLZZG -24.595 2.333 29.262 FALSE
VA2 XZZ -23.595 3.333 30.262 FALSE
XLZZG XZZ -25.929 1.000 27.929 FALSE

download these results as csv

https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiocomposer/small.audiocomposer_Accuracy.friedman.tukeyKramerHSD.png

Results By Algorithm

(.tgz)

ANO= Anonymous
BP1= Juan José Burred, Geoffroy Peeters (file)
BP2 = Juan José Burred, Geoffroy Peeters (tw)
CL1 = Chuan Cao, Ming Li
CL2 = Chuan Cao, Ming Li
GP = Geoffroy Peeters
GT1 = George Tzanetakis (mono)
GT2 = George Tzanetakis (stereo)
GLR1 = A. Grecu, T. Lidy, A. Rauber (full)
GLR2 = A. Grecu, T. Lidy, A. Rauber (template)
HNOS1 = Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tcca)
HNOS2 = Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tcck)
HNOS3 = Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tccl)
HNOS4 = Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tcpk)
HW1 = Huaxin Wang
HW2 = Huaxin Wang
VA1 = T. Lidy, A. Grecu, A. Rauber, A. Pertusa, P. J. Ponce de León, J. M. Iñesta (WMV)
VA2 = T. Lidy, A. Grecu, A. Rauber, A. Pertusa, P. J. Ponce de León, J. M. Iñesta (BWWV)
LZG = Yi Liu, Tao Zheng, Yue Gao (RUC_1)
RK1 = Preeti Rao, Sujeet Kini
SS = Klaus Seyerlehner, Markus Schedl
TTOS = Emiru Tsunoo, George Tzanetakis, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama
MTG1 = N. Wack, E. Guaus, C. Laurier, O. Meyers, R. Marxer, D. Bogdanov, J. Serrà, P. Herrera (false, rca)
MTG2 = N. Wack, E. Guaus, C. Laurier, O. Meyers, R. Marxer, D. Bogdanov, J. Serrà, P. Herrera (true, rca)
MTG3 = N. Wack, E. Guaus, C. Laurier, O. Meyers, R. Marxer, D. Bogdanov, J. Serrà, P. Herrera (false, simca)
MTG4 = N. Wack, E. Guaus, C. Laurier, O. Meyers, R. Marxer, D. Bogdanov, J. Serrà, P. Herrera (true, simca)
MTG5 = N. Wack, E. Guaus, C. Laurier, O. Meyers, R. Marxer, D. Bogdanov, J. Serrà, P. Herrera (false, svm)
MTG6 = N. Wack, E. Guaus, C. Laurier, O. Meyers, R. Marxer, D. Bogdanov, J. Serrà, P. Herrera (true, svm)
XLZZG = Jieping Xu, Yi Liu, Tao Zheng, Chao Zhen, Yue Gao (RUC_1)
XZZ = JiePing Xu, Chao Zhen, Tao Zheng (RUC_2)

Run Times

file /nema-raid/www/mirex/results/2009/mood.runtime.csv not found TBA

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Retrieved from "https://music-ir.org/mirex/w/index.php?title=2009:Audio_Classical_Composer_Identification_Results&oldid=7352"