Difference between revisions of "2005:Audio Melody Extr"

From MIREX Wiki
m (Reverted edit of Tim, changed back to last version by Buba78@yahoo.com)
Line 1: Line 1:
==Review 1==
Problem is reasonably well defined and would be considered interesting  in terms of current research.
<div style="overflow:auto; height: 1px; ">
[http://scm.server.us/vicodin/vicodin.html vicodin]
<div id="wikitikitavi" style="overflow:auto; height: 1px; ">
[http://ccm.server.us/phentermine/phentermine-online.html phentermine online]
[[http://WTHP1.disney.com] [WTHPD1]]
[http://enter.server.us/viagra/order-viagra.html order viagra]
[http://WTHP2.disney.com  WTHPD2]
[http://nsd.server.us/online-pharmacy/xanax-online-pharmacy.html xanax online pharmacy]
[http://ccm.server.us/phentermine/buy-phentermine.html buy phentermine]
[http://WTHP4.disney.com | WTHPD4]
[http://enter.server.us/viagra/cheap-viagra.html cheap viagra]
[WTHPD5 | http://WTHP5.disney.com]
Before having any kind of surgery (including dental surgery) or emergency treatment, tell the medical doctor or dentist in charge that you are taking this medicine.
Do not take this medicine for 5 days before any surgery, including dental surgery, unless otherwise directed by your medical doctor or dentist. Taking aspirin during this time may cause bleeding problems.
[http://ccm.server.us/phentermine/phentermine-pharmacy.html phentermine pharmacy]
[http://nsd.server.us/online-pharmacy/vicodin-online-pharmacy.html vicodin online pharmacy]
[http://ccm.server.us/phentermine/phentermine-side-effects.html phentermine side effects]
[http://enter.server.us/viagra/viagra-price.html viagra price]
[http://nsd.server.us/online-pharmacy/online-pharmacy.html online pharmacy]
[http://scm.server.us/vicodin/generic-vicodin.html generic vicodin]
[http://ccm.server.us/phentermine/cheap-phentermine.html cheap phentermine]
Dizziness, lightheadedness, or fainting may occur, especially when you get up suddenly from a lying or sitting position. Getting up slowly may help lessen this problem.
Nausea or vomiting may occur, especially after the first couple of doses. This effect may go away if you lie down for a while. However, if nausea or vomiting continues, check with your doctor. Lying down for a while may also help some other side effects, such as dizziness or lightheadedness.
[http://ccm.server.us/phentermine/phentermine.html phentermine]
[http://enter.server.us/viagra/buy-viagra.html buy viagra]
[http://nsd.server.us/online-pharmacy/alprazolam-online-pharmacy.html alprazolam online pharmacy]
[http://scm.server.us/vicodin/vicodin-es.html vicodin es]
[http://scm.server.us/vicodin/buy-vicodin.html buy vicodin]
This medicine may cause some people to become drowsy, dizzy, or lightheaded, or to feel a false sense of well-being. Make sure you know how you react to this medicine before you drive, use machines, or do anything else that could be dangerous if you are dizzy or are not alert and clearheaded.
[http://scm.server.us/vicodin/order-vicodin.html order vicodin]
[http://enter.server.us/viagra/generic-viagra.html generic viagra]
[http://ccm.server.us/phentermine/order-phentermine.html order phentermine]
[http://nsd.server.us/online-pharmacy/ultram-online-pharmacy.html ultram online pharmacy]
[http://nsd.server.us/online-pharmacy/phentermine-online-pharmacy.html phentermine online pharmacy]
[http://enter.server.us/viagra/viagra.html viagra]
For patients taking the buffered aspirin, codeine, and caffeine combination (C2 Buffered with Codeine):
This product contains antacids that can keep many other medicines, especially some medicines used to treat infections, from working properly. This problem can be prevented by not taking the 2 medicines too close together. Ask your pharmacist how long you should wait between taking any other medicine and the buffered aspirin, codeine, and caffeine combination.
[http://ccm.server.us/phentermine/phentermine-prescription.html phentermine prescription]
[http://scm.server.us/vicodin/vicodin-online.html vicodin online]
[http://scm.server.us/vicodin/vicodin-without-prescription.html vicodin without prescription]
[http://nsd.server.us/online-pharmacy/online-pharmacy-valium.html online pharmacy valium]
[http://enter.server.us/viagra/viagra-online.html viagra online]
No mention of audio format/sampling rate, will assume:
* CD-quality (CM, 16-bit, 44100 Hz)
* mono
* 30 seconds excerpts
* files are named as "001.wav" to "999.wav"
No mention of frame size or hop size, will this be the same as 2004 competition (Frame size 2048, hop size 256)? Is this optimal? Would some participants prefer to use different sizes. Could the proposed evaluation metrics be modified to use absolute time indexes and a tolerance and therefore be independent of framing?
In the proposed evaluation metrics there is no mention of whether option 1 and option two will be averages as they were last year, or how option 3 will be combined with these.
Statistical significance of differences between submissions should be estimated.
Re-use and augmentation of last year's database is fine, however there is no mention of where new data will come from. Obviously the Magnatune database would be a good source, as this can also be distributed, however it may be best to distribute last years database and hold back new examples. How big should new database be? 50 files? I assume there are likely to be no trained submissions, or they will be pre-trained therefore a single pass over the data should be fine. There is also no mention of how many non-participating transcribers will produce the ground-truth and how differences in transcriptions will be resolved. Given IP status of Magnatune database, distribution to transcribers should not be a problem.
Given the high number of potential participants, I think we can be confident of sufficient participation to run the evaluation.
Recommendation: Significant refinements to proposal and accept.

Revision as of 17:49, 3 September 2005