2006:Evalutron6000 Walkthrough For Symbolic Melodic Similarity

Welcome to Evalutron 6000

Basic Requirements

In order to use Evalutron 6000 you will need a modern web browser (e.g., Firefox, Mozilla, Safari, Internet Explorer ) that supports JavaScript (ECMAScript) and Cookies. Evalutron has been tested on Windows XP, MacOS X, and RedHat Linux. We have found that the combination of Firefox and Flash Player to be most stable. Despite our best efforts, the use of Internet Explorer continues to generate seemingly random errors and we ask that you avoid using Internet Explorer. A decent amount of bandwidth is also advisable to minimize download times (i.e., DSL, cable modem and better).

A screen resolution of 1024 X 768 the minimal advised. Higher resolutions appear to work well too. We have noted some odd behaviour if you adjust your resolution in mid-session, so probably best to not to do this. Adjusting font size via you browser can sometimes make things look a bit tidier and does not seem to have adverse effects.

If you are having trouble, please try accessing Evalutron 6000 from another machine. If you are still having difficulty, contact

mrx-com09@lists.lis.uiuc.edu.

Getting Started

When first visiting the Evalutron 6000 homepage, you will see a page similar to this (Fig. 1).

Figure 1. Evalutron 6000 start page.

First you must register a new account. Click on the "Register" link (listed under Step 2) on the page to create an account.

The registration page is fairly straightforward (Fig. 2). Required fields are marked in blue with an asterisks. You can create any username and password you wish. Passwords must be at least 6 characters long and are case-sensitive. Before completing the registration, you must read and agree to the terms of the Informed Consent document. The evaluation, because it is using human judgements of similarity, is considered a human-subjects research project and the Evaluatron is basically a survey instrument. To indicate your consent to participate in the evaluation, check the "I Agree" checkbox below the informed consent document.

If you have questions about your rights as a subject in this research project, you should contact the UIUC IRB office (http://www.irb.uiuc.edu) for more information. The research protocol for this project is IRB# 07066.

Figure 2. Evalutron 6000 registration page.

After completing the Registration, the system will ask you to sign-in with your newly created username and password. After signing-in, you can begin evaluation (Fig. 3). To start the evaluation process, click on the "Start Evaluation" link on the homepage. You will be presented with several options for what media player you want to use. We have invested considerable effort coding various interfaces to be compatible with the maximum number of browsers, platforms, and players. Most users should be able to use the Flash MP3 Player option -- which we've found to work the best. The Windows Media Player and Quicktime options should also work in most modern browsers. We have noted that the Media Player does introduce some start-up lags when starting a new query set which we believe is caused by the way Media Player downloads the MP3 files.

Figure 3. Audio player selection page.

Once you have selected a player configuration, you'll see a query evaluation page (Fig. 4). On this page, you will see the query player and the list of candidate players. The queries and candidates drawn from the RISM collection are fairly short (Queries #1 through #6). We recommend you listen to the entire query at least once before evaluating any candidate files.

Figure 4. Sample evaluation page.

Please do not be puzzled if your first query assignment is not Query #1 or if your Candidate List has candidates in seemingly random order: This is deliberate! The Evalutron 6000 is designed to build customized randomized lists and orderings for each grader to minimize fatigue and ordering effects. While you have the right to jump around in the system to do your evaluations in any order you like, we would appreciate it if you followed the suggested ordering given by the Evalutron 6000's randomizer. The "Previous Query" and "Next Query" buttons visible Figure 4 are designed to guide you through the randomized Query List ordering.

Please note that the list of candidates is longer than the visible page (i.e., there are more candidates than may be immediately visible on the page). Please scroll to the bottom of the candidate list to make sure you have evaluated each song.

The procedure for listening to a candidate is the same as listening to a query -- click the play buttons to load the clip into the player and listen to it (Fig. 5). Once you have a feeling for how similar the candidate is to the query, click the "Not Similar," "Somewhat Similar" or "Very Similar" radio buttons to the right of the candidate. Note: you can continue to replay the query during candidate playback.

Figure 5. Close up image of candidate manipulation buttons.

Depending on how you graded the candidate, you should see the candidate box react to your grade, indicating that the vote has been logged in the database (Fig. 6). If you indicated the song was "Somewhat Similar" the box will turn yellow and state "SAVED". If you indicated the song was "Very Similar" the box will turn green, "Not Similar" the box will turn red, and state "SAVED".

Figure 6. Close up image of candidate manipulation buttons with "Somewhat Similar" selection "SAVED".

You can also assign a fine score for the similarity of the candidate to the query in the scale of 0-10 (Fig. 7).

Figure 7. Close up image of candidate manipulation scale.

The system will automatically record the score when you let go of the button on the scale (Fig. 8).

Figure 8. Close up image of candidate manipulation scale with a random score "SAVED".

You can always change your evaluation for any candidate by toggling the radio buttons. The system should reflect any changes with an appropriate color change. Once an evaluation has been made, however, it cannot be retracted, only reversed. (i.e., you cannot "unvote").

When you have completed evaluating all of the candidates for a single query, you can click on the "Next Query" button at the top right of the evaluation page. This button will load a new query and list of candidates for you to evaluate. Under "My Assignment", you can check the list of queries and candidates that were assigned to you, and also see how far you are in completing your evaluation task (Fig. 9).

Figure 9. My Assignment page.

You will also see a list of all of the queries you have evaluated (or are evaluating) at the bottom of the page. You can return to any query by clicking on the button for that query here (Fig. 10). You can re-evaluate any candidate for any query at any time, up to the closing of the evaluation system.

Figure 10. Close up image of Query List buttons which allow for revisiting of completed query/candidate sets.