Difference between revisions of "2009:Audio Genre Classification (Mixed Set) Results"

Latest revision as of 15:02, 23 July 2010

1 Introduction
- 1.1 General Legend
  - 1.1.1 Team ID
2 Overall Summary Results
3 Friedman's Tests for Significant Differences
- 3.1 Classes vs. System Tukey-Kramer HSD Multi-Comparisons
- 3.2 Folds vs. Systems Tukey-Kramer HSD Multi-Comparison
4 Hierarchical-Discounted Scoring Results
5 Results By Algorithm
6 Run Times

Introduction

These are the results for the 2008 running of the Audio Genre Classification (Mixed Set) task. For background information about this task set please refer to the 2009:Audio Genre Classification page.

Mixed Set collection statistics: 7000 30-second audio clips in 22.05kHz mono WAV format drawn from 10 genres (700 clips from each genre). Genres:

Blues
Jazz
Country/Western
Baroque
Classical
Romantic
Electronica
Hip-Hop
Rock
HardRock/Metal

General Legend

Team ID

ANO= Anonymous
BP1= Juan José Burred, Geoffroy Peeters (file)
BP2 = Juan José Burred, Geoffroy Peeters (tw)
CL1 = Chuan Cao, Ming Li
CL2 = Chuan Cao, Ming Li
GP = Geoffroy Peeters
GT1 = George Tzanetakis (mono)
GT2 = George Tzanetakis (stereo)
GLR1 = Andrei Grecu, Thomas Lidy, Andreas Rauber (full)
GLR2 = Andrei Grecu, Thomas Lidy, Andreas Rauber (template)
HNOS1 = Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tcca)
HNOS2 = Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tcck)
HNOS3 = Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tccl)
HNOS4 = Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tcpk)
HW1 = Huaxin Wang
HW2 = Huaxin Wang
VA1 = Thomas Lidy,Andrei Grecu, Andreas Rauber, A. Pertusa, Pedro J. Ponce de León, J. M. Iñesta (WMV)
VA2 = Thomas Lidy, Andrei Grecu, Andreas Rauber, A. Pertusa, Pedro J. Ponce de León, J. M. Iñesta (BWWV)
LZG = Yi Liu, Tao Zheng, Yue Gao (RUC_1)
RCJ1 = Jia-Min Ren, Zhi-Sheng Chen, Jyh-Shing Roger Jang
RCJ3 = Jia-Min Ren, Zhi-Sheng Chen, Jyh-Shing Roger Jang
RCJ4 = Jia-Min Ren, Zhi-Sheng Chen, Jyh-Shing Roger Jang
RK1 = Preeti Rao, Sujeet Kini
SS = Klaus Seyerlehner, Markus Schedl
TTOS = Emiru Tsunoo, George Tzanetakis, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama
MTG1 = Nicolas Wack, Enric Guaus, Cyril Laurier, Owen Meyers, Ricard Marxer, Dmitry Bogdanov, Joan Serrà, Perfecto Herrera (false, rca)
MTG3 = Nicolas Wack, Enric Guaus, Cyril Laurier, Owen Meyers, Ricard Marxer, Dmitry Bogdanov, Joan Serrà, Perfecto Herrera (false, simca)
MTG4 = Nicolas Wack, Enric Guaus, Cyril Laurier, Owen Meyers, Ricard Marxer, Dmitry Bogdanov, Joan Serrà, Perfecto Herrera(true, simca)
MTG5 = Nicolas Wack, Enric Guaus, Cyril Laurier, Owen Meyers, Ricard Marxer, Dmitry Bogdanov, Joan Serrà, Perfecto Herrera(false, svm)
XLZZG = Jieping Xu, Yi Liu, Tao Zheng, Chao Zhen, Yue Gao (RUC_1)
XZZ = JiePing Xu, Chao Zhen, Tao Zheng (RUC_2)

Overall Summary Results

Raw Classification Accuracy Averaged Over Three Train/Test Folds

Participant	Mean Accuracy	Mean Discounted Accuracy
ANO	60.50%	70.60%
BP1	70.63%	77.61%
BP2	68.51%	76.21%
CL1	73.23%	80.48%
CL2	73.33%	80.61%
GLR1	71.23%	78.51%
GLR2	60.14%	69.11%
GP	64.24%	72.97%
GT1	65.10%	73.68%
GT2	67.87%	76.21%
HNOS1	64.47%	72.96%
HNOS2	20.90%	23.22%
HNOS3	64.34%	72.97%
HNOS4	45.16%	55.09%
HW1	65.99%	74.33%
HW2	65.31%	73.68%
LZG	68.29%	76.29%
MTG1	64.79%	73.05%
MTG3	64.06%	71.95%
MTG4	64.00%	71.69%
MTG5	70.44%	77.69%
RCJ1	32.50%	44.08%
RCJ3	37.71%	49.46%
RCJ4	50.99%	61.2%
RK1	61.41%	70.20%
SS	66.60%	74.54%
TTOS	67.89%	76.47%
VA1	68.84%	76.53%
VA2	67.39%	75.56%
XLZZG	68.93%	76.54%
XZZ	69.36%	77.25%

download these results as csv

Accuracy Across Folds

Classification fold	ANO	BP1	BP2	CL1	CL2	GLR1	GLR2	GP	GT1	GT2	HNOS1	HNOS2	HNOS3	HNOS4	HW1	HW2	LZG	MTG1	MTG3	MTG4	MTG5	RCJ1	RCJ3	RCJ4	RK1	SS	TTOS	VA1	VA2	XLZZG	XZZ
0	0.585	0.684	0.663	0.706	0.705	0.697	0.591	0.640	0.644	0.666	0.643	0.249	0.637	0.479	0.637	0.638	0.661	0.622	0.639	0.627	0.679	0.321	0.382	0.497	0.606	0.651	0.663	0.673	0.661	0.670	0.685
1	0.616	0.731	0.692	0.743	0.750	0.725	0.608	0.638	0.658	0.698	0.647	0.189	0.648	0.448	0.691	0.681	0.690	0.669	0.641	0.652	0.725	0.342	0.376	0.525	0.626	0.689	0.692	0.701	0.680	0.704	0.701
2	0.614	0.704	0.701	0.748	0.745	0.715	0.605	0.649	0.651	0.672	0.644	0.189	0.646	0.428	0.652	0.640	0.698	0.653	0.641	0.642	0.710	0.312	0.374	0.507	0.611	0.658	0.682	0.692	0.682	0.693	0.694

download these results as csv

Accuracy Across Categories

Class	ANO	BP1	BP2	CL1	CL2	GLR1	GLR2	GP	GT1	GT2	HNOS1	HNOS2	HNOS3	HNOS4	HW1	HW2	LZG	MTG1	MTG3	MTG4	MTG5	RCJ1	RCJ3	RCJ4	RK1	SS	TTOS	VA1	VA2	XLZZG	XZZ
baroque	0.653	0.730	0.773	0.787	0.792	0.793	0.611	0.747	0.656	0.700	0.633	0.011	0.636	0.107	0.750	0.730	0.790	0.754	0.736	0.749	0.743	0.454	0.544	0.539	0.684	0.744	0.659	0.739	0.746	0.777	0.820
blues	0.595	0.717	0.717	0.809	0.821	0.747	0.704	0.684	0.709	0.704	0.713	0.000	0.708	0.497	0.663	0.669	0.660	0.706	0.723	0.719	0.730	0.270	0.514	0.624	0.664	0.723	0.733	0.733	0.797	0.673	0.691
classical	0.487	0.692	0.635	0.642	0.639	0.686	0.569	0.606	0.623	0.689	0.666	0.045	0.676	0.770	0.589	0.572	0.649	0.675	0.589	0.566	0.627	0.524	0.422	0.512	0.679	0.682	0.635	0.649	0.625	0.662	0.683
country	0.676	0.834	0.834	0.787	0.794	0.760	0.617	0.701	0.607	0.706	0.660	0.036	0.651	0.157	0.734	0.719	0.757	0.717	0.480	0.483	0.704	0.266	0.426	0.540	0.571	0.703	0.699	0.727	0.736	0.729	0.784
edance	0.692	0.630	0.629	0.737	0.747	0.730	0.530	0.536	0.659	0.699	0.587	0.419	0.583	0.831	0.596	0.581	0.680	0.541	0.790	0.790	0.736	0.153	0.263	0.579	0.520	0.664	0.690	0.664	0.659	0.704	0.693
jazz	0.597	0.736	0.732	0.827	0.826	0.714	0.554	0.607	0.659	0.679	0.624	0.000	0.629	0.090	0.674	0.663	0.687	0.637	0.716	0.729	0.766	0.191	0.274	0.436	0.563	0.660	0.692	0.659	0.570	0.697	0.692
metal	0.617	0.712	0.730	0.807	0.806	0.790	0.720	0.750	0.723	0.741	0.717	0.548	0.707	0.607	0.782	0.783	0.714	0.666	0.710	0.700	0.733	0.538	0.423	0.533	0.719	0.637	0.710	0.760	0.752	0.702	0.746
raphiphop	0.781	0.850	0.844	0.911	0.911	0.911	0.811	0.867	0.873	0.869	0.814	0.944	0.827	0.860	0.873	0.866	0.847	0.831	0.804	0.799	0.877	0.139	0.433	0.716	0.853	0.837	0.876	0.886	0.893	0.854	0.870
rockroll	0.416	0.539	0.413	0.430	0.424	0.391	0.323	0.417	0.443	0.477	0.503	0.056	0.497	0.359	0.417	0.412	0.504	0.441	0.414	0.388	0.520	0.334	0.223	0.293	0.420	0.424	0.517	0.486	0.397	0.516	0.489
romantic	0.538	0.624	0.546	0.586	0.573	0.600	0.574	0.509	0.560	0.524	0.530	0.029	0.521	0.238	0.522	0.539	0.540	0.510	0.444	0.478	0.608	0.379	0.250	0.329	0.469	0.586	0.580	0.583	0.566	0.580	0.469

download these results as csv

Friedman's Tests for Significant Differences

Classes vs. System Tukey-Kramer HSD Multi-Comparisons

The Friedman test was run in MATLAB against the average accuracy for each class. The Tukey-Kramer HSD multi-comparison data below was generated using the following MATLAB instruction. Command:
[c, m, h, gnames] = multicompare(stats, 'ctype', 'tukey-kramer', 'estimate', 'friedman', 'alpha', 0.05);

TeamID	TeamID	Lowerbound	Mean	Upperbound	Significance
ANO	BP1	-15.808	-0.500	14.808	FALSE
ANO	BP2	-14.508	0.800	16.108	FALSE
ANO	CL1	-11.708	3.600	18.908	FALSE
ANO	CL2	-12.508	2.800	18.108	FALSE
ANO	GLR1	-10.708	4.600	19.908	FALSE
ANO	GLR2	-9.508	5.800	21.108	FALSE
ANO	GP	-10.608	4.700	20.008	FALSE
ANO	GT1	-8.408	6.900	22.208	FALSE
ANO	GT2	-8.208	7.100	22.408	FALSE
ANO	HNOS1	-8.808	6.500	21.808	FALSE
ANO	HNOS2	-8.508	6.800	22.108	FALSE
ANO	HNOS3	-8.108	7.200	22.508	FALSE
ANO	HNOS4	-7.108	8.200	23.508	FALSE
ANO	HW1	-6.108	9.200	24.508	FALSE
ANO	HW2	-4.208	11.100	26.408	FALSE
ANO	LZG	-5.208	10.100	25.408	FALSE
ANO	MTG1	-4.108	11.200	26.508	FALSE
ANO	MTG3	-3.708	11.600	26.908	FALSE
ANO	MTG4	-2.908	12.400	27.708	FALSE
ANO	MTG5	-3.208	12.100	27.408	FALSE
ANO	RCJ1	-3.708	11.600	26.908	FALSE
ANO	RCJ3	-3.108	12.200	27.508	FALSE
ANO	RCJ4	-1.008	14.300	29.608	FALSE
ANO	RK1	1.092	16.400	31.708	TRUE
ANO	SS	0.992	16.300	31.608	TRUE
ANO	TTOS	6.392	21.700	37.008	TRUE
ANO	VA1	0.892	16.200	31.508	TRUE
ANO	VA2	8.092	23.400	38.708	TRUE
ANO	XLZZG	7.892	23.200	38.508	TRUE
ANO	XZZ	6.492	21.800	37.108	TRUE
BP1	BP2	-14.008	1.300	16.608	FALSE
BP1	CL1	-11.208	4.100	19.408	FALSE
BP1	CL2	-12.008	3.300	18.608	FALSE
BP1	GLR1	-10.208	5.100	20.408	FALSE
BP1	GLR2	-9.008	6.300	21.608	FALSE
BP1	GP	-10.108	5.200	20.508	FALSE
BP1	GT1	-7.908	7.400	22.708	FALSE
BP1	GT2	-7.708	7.600	22.908	FALSE
BP1	HNOS1	-8.308	7.000	22.308	FALSE
BP1	HNOS2	-8.008	7.300	22.608	FALSE
BP1	HNOS3	-7.608	7.700	23.008	FALSE
BP1	HNOS4	-6.608	8.700	24.008	FALSE
BP1	HW1	-5.608	9.700	25.008	FALSE
BP1	HW2	-3.708	11.600	26.908	FALSE
BP1	LZG	-4.708	10.600	25.908	FALSE
BP1	MTG1	-3.608	11.700	27.008	FALSE
BP1	MTG3	-3.208	12.100	27.408	FALSE
BP1	MTG4	-2.408	12.900	28.208	FALSE
BP1	MTG5	-2.708	12.600	27.908	FALSE
BP1	RCJ1	-3.208	12.100	27.408	FALSE
BP1	RCJ3	-2.608	12.700	28.008	FALSE
BP1	RCJ4	-0.508	14.800	30.108	FALSE
BP1	RK1	1.592	16.900	32.208	TRUE
BP1	SS	1.492	16.800	32.108	TRUE
BP1	TTOS	6.892	22.200	37.508	TRUE
BP1	VA1	1.392	16.700	32.008	TRUE
BP1	VA2	8.592	23.900	39.208	TRUE
BP1	XLZZG	8.392	23.700	39.008	TRUE
BP1	XZZ	6.992	22.300	37.608	TRUE
BP2	CL1	-12.508	2.800	18.108	FALSE
BP2	CL2	-13.308	2.000	17.308	FALSE
BP2	GLR1	-11.508	3.800	19.108	FALSE
BP2	GLR2	-10.308	5.000	20.308	FALSE
BP2	GP	-11.408	3.900	19.208	FALSE
BP2	GT1	-9.208	6.100	21.408	FALSE
BP2	GT2	-9.008	6.300	21.608	FALSE
BP2	HNOS1	-9.608	5.700	21.008	FALSE
BP2	HNOS2	-9.308	6.000	21.308	FALSE
BP2	HNOS3	-8.908	6.400	21.708	FALSE
BP2	HNOS4	-7.908	7.400	22.708	FALSE
BP2	HW1	-6.908	8.400	23.708	FALSE
BP2	HW2	-5.008	10.300	25.608	FALSE
BP2	LZG	-6.008	9.300	24.608	FALSE
BP2	MTG1	-4.908	10.400	25.708	FALSE
BP2	MTG3	-4.508	10.800	26.108	FALSE
BP2	MTG4	-3.708	11.600	26.908	FALSE
BP2	MTG5	-4.008	11.300	26.608	FALSE
BP2	RCJ1	-4.508	10.800	26.108	FALSE
BP2	RCJ3	-3.908	11.400	26.708	FALSE
BP2	RCJ4	-1.808	13.500	28.808	FALSE
BP2	RK1	0.292	15.600	30.908	TRUE
BP2	SS	0.192	15.500	30.808	TRUE
BP2	TTOS	5.592	20.900	36.208	TRUE
BP2	VA1	0.092	15.400	30.708	TRUE
BP2	VA2	7.292	22.600	37.908	TRUE
BP2	XLZZG	7.092	22.400	37.708	TRUE
BP2	XZZ	5.692	21.000	36.308	TRUE
CL1	CL2	-16.108	-0.800	14.508	FALSE
CL1	GLR1	-14.308	1.000	16.308	FALSE
CL1	GLR2	-13.108	2.200	17.508	FALSE
CL1	GP	-14.208	1.100	16.408	FALSE
CL1	GT1	-12.008	3.300	18.608	FALSE
CL1	GT2	-11.808	3.500	18.808	FALSE
CL1	HNOS1	-12.408	2.900	18.208	FALSE
CL1	HNOS2	-12.108	3.200	18.508	FALSE
CL1	HNOS3	-11.708	3.600	18.908	FALSE
CL1	HNOS4	-10.708	4.600	19.908	FALSE
CL1	HW1	-9.708	5.600	20.908	FALSE
CL1	HW2	-7.808	7.500	22.808	FALSE
CL1	LZG	-8.808	6.500	21.808	FALSE
CL1	MTG1	-7.708	7.600	22.908	FALSE
CL1	MTG3	-7.308	8.000	23.308	FALSE
CL1	MTG4	-6.508	8.800	24.108	FALSE
CL1	MTG5	-6.808	8.500	23.808	FALSE
CL1	RCJ1	-7.308	8.000	23.308	FALSE
CL1	RCJ3	-6.708	8.600	23.908	FALSE
CL1	RCJ4	-4.608	10.700	26.008	FALSE
CL1	RK1	-2.508	12.800	28.108	FALSE
CL1	SS	-2.608	12.700	28.008	FALSE
CL1	TTOS	2.792	18.100	33.408	TRUE
CL1	VA1	-2.708	12.600	27.908	FALSE
CL1	VA2	4.492	19.800	35.108	TRUE
CL1	XLZZG	4.292	19.600	34.908	TRUE
CL1	XZZ	2.892	18.200	33.508	TRUE
CL2	GLR1	-13.508	1.800	17.108	FALSE
CL2	GLR2	-12.308	3.000	18.308	FALSE
CL2	GP	-13.408	1.900	17.208	FALSE
CL2	GT1	-11.208	4.100	19.408	FALSE
CL2	GT2	-11.008	4.300	19.608	FALSE
CL2	HNOS1	-11.608	3.700	19.008	FALSE
CL2	HNOS2	-11.308	4.000	19.308	FALSE
CL2	HNOS3	-10.908	4.400	19.708	FALSE
CL2	HNOS4	-9.908	5.400	20.708	FALSE
CL2	HW1	-8.908	6.400	21.708	FALSE
CL2	HW2	-7.008	8.300	23.608	FALSE
CL2	LZG	-8.008	7.300	22.608	FALSE
CL2	MTG1	-6.908	8.400	23.708	FALSE
CL2	MTG3	-6.508	8.800	24.108	FALSE
CL2	MTG4	-5.708	9.600	24.908	FALSE
CL2	MTG5	-6.008	9.300	24.608	FALSE
CL2	RCJ1	-6.508	8.800	24.108	FALSE
CL2	RCJ3	-5.908	9.400	24.708	FALSE
CL2	RCJ4	-3.808	11.500	26.808	FALSE
CL2	RK1	-1.708	13.600	28.908	FALSE
CL2	SS	-1.808	13.500	28.808	FALSE
CL2	TTOS	3.592	18.900	34.208	TRUE
CL2	VA1	-1.908	13.400	28.708	FALSE
CL2	VA2	5.292	20.600	35.908	TRUE
CL2	XLZZG	5.092	20.400	35.708	TRUE
CL2	XZZ	3.692	19.000	34.308	TRUE
GLR1	GLR2	-14.108	1.200	16.508	FALSE
GLR1	GP	-15.208	0.100	15.408	FALSE
GLR1	GT1	-13.008	2.300	17.608	FALSE
GLR1	GT2	-12.808	2.500	17.808	FALSE
GLR1	HNOS1	-13.408	1.900	17.208	FALSE
GLR1	HNOS2	-13.108	2.200	17.508	FALSE
GLR1	HNOS3	-12.708	2.600	17.908	FALSE
GLR1	HNOS4	-11.708	3.600	18.908	FALSE
GLR1	HW1	-10.708	4.600	19.908	FALSE
GLR1	HW2	-8.808	6.500	21.808	FALSE
GLR1	LZG	-9.808	5.500	20.808	FALSE
GLR1	MTG1	-8.708	6.600	21.908	FALSE
GLR1	MTG3	-8.308	7.000	22.308	FALSE
GLR1	MTG4	-7.508	7.800	23.108	FALSE
GLR1	MTG5	-7.808	7.500	22.808	FALSE
GLR1	RCJ1	-8.308	7.000	22.308	FALSE
GLR1	RCJ3	-7.708	7.600	22.908	FALSE
GLR1	RCJ4	-5.608	9.700	25.008	FALSE
GLR1	RK1	-3.508	11.800	27.108	FALSE
GLR1	SS	-3.608	11.700	27.008	FALSE
GLR1	TTOS	1.792	17.100	32.408	TRUE
GLR1	VA1	-3.708	11.600	26.908	FALSE
GLR1	VA2	3.492	18.800	34.108	TRUE
GLR1	XLZZG	3.292	18.600	33.908	TRUE
GLR1	XZZ	1.892	17.200	32.508	TRUE
GLR2	GP	-16.408	-1.100	14.208	FALSE
GLR2	GT1	-14.208	1.100	16.408	FALSE
GLR2	GT2	-14.008	1.300	16.608	FALSE
GLR2	HNOS1	-14.608	0.700	16.008	FALSE
GLR2	HNOS2	-14.308	1.000	16.308	FALSE
GLR2	HNOS3	-13.908	1.400	16.708	FALSE
GLR2	HNOS4	-12.908	2.400	17.708	FALSE
GLR2	HW1	-11.908	3.400	18.708	FALSE
GLR2	HW2	-10.008	5.300	20.608	FALSE
GLR2	LZG	-11.008	4.300	19.608	FALSE
GLR2	MTG1	-9.908	5.400	20.708	FALSE
GLR2	MTG3	-9.508	5.800	21.108	FALSE
GLR2	MTG4	-8.708	6.600	21.908	FALSE
GLR2	MTG5	-9.008	6.300	21.608	FALSE
GLR2	RCJ1	-9.508	5.800	21.108	FALSE
GLR2	RCJ3	-8.908	6.400	21.708	FALSE
GLR2	RCJ4	-6.808	8.500	23.808	FALSE
GLR2	RK1	-4.708	10.600	25.908	FALSE
GLR2	SS	-4.808	10.500	25.808	FALSE
GLR2	TTOS	0.592	15.900	31.208	TRUE
GLR2	VA1	-4.908	10.400	25.708	FALSE
GLR2	VA2	2.292	17.600	32.908	TRUE
GLR2	XLZZG	2.092	17.400	32.708	TRUE
GLR2	XZZ	0.692	16.000	31.308	TRUE
GP	GT1	-13.108	2.200	17.508	FALSE
GP	GT2	-12.908	2.400	17.708	FALSE
GP	HNOS1	-13.508	1.800	17.108	FALSE
GP	HNOS2	-13.208	2.100	17.408	FALSE
GP	HNOS3	-12.808	2.500	17.808	FALSE
GP	HNOS4	-11.808	3.500	18.808	FALSE
GP	HW1	-10.808	4.500	19.808	FALSE
GP	HW2	-8.908	6.400	21.708	FALSE
GP	LZG	-9.908	5.400	20.708	FALSE
GP	MTG1	-8.808	6.500	21.808	FALSE
GP	MTG3	-8.408	6.900	22.208	FALSE
GP	MTG4	-7.608	7.700	23.008	FALSE
GP	MTG5	-7.908	7.400	22.708	FALSE
GP	RCJ1	-8.408	6.900	22.208	FALSE
GP	RCJ3	-7.808	7.500	22.808	FALSE
GP	RCJ4	-5.708	9.600	24.908	FALSE
GP	RK1	-3.608	11.700	27.008	FALSE
GP	SS	-3.708	11.600	26.908	FALSE
GP	TTOS	1.692	17.000	32.308	TRUE
GP	VA1	-3.808	11.500	26.808	FALSE
GP	VA2	3.392	18.700	34.008	TRUE
GP	XLZZG	3.192	18.500	33.808	TRUE
GP	XZZ	1.792	17.100	32.408	TRUE
GT1	GT2	-15.108	0.200	15.508	FALSE
GT1	HNOS1	-15.708	-0.400	14.908	FALSE
GT1	HNOS2	-15.408	-0.100	15.208	FALSE
GT1	HNOS3	-15.008	0.300	15.608	FALSE
GT1	HNOS4	-14.008	1.300	16.608	FALSE
GT1	HW1	-13.008	2.300	17.608	FALSE
GT1	HW2	-11.108	4.200	19.508	FALSE
GT1	LZG	-12.108	3.200	18.508	FALSE
GT1	MTG1	-11.008	4.300	19.608	FALSE
GT1	MTG3	-10.608	4.700	20.008	FALSE
GT1	MTG4	-9.808	5.500	20.808	FALSE
GT1	MTG5	-10.108	5.200	20.508	FALSE
GT1	RCJ1	-10.608	4.700	20.008	FALSE
GT1	RCJ3	-10.008	5.300	20.608	FALSE
GT1	RCJ4	-7.908	7.400	22.708	FALSE
GT1	RK1	-5.808	9.500	24.808	FALSE
GT1	SS	-5.908	9.400	24.708	FALSE
GT1	TTOS	-0.508	14.800	30.108	FALSE
GT1	VA1	-6.008	9.300	24.608	FALSE
GT1	VA2	1.192	16.500	31.808	TRUE
GT1	XLZZG	0.992	16.300	31.608	TRUE
GT1	XZZ	-0.408	14.900	30.208	FALSE
GT2	HNOS1	-15.908	-0.600	14.708	FALSE
GT2	HNOS2	-15.608	-0.300	15.008	FALSE
GT2	HNOS3	-15.208	0.100	15.408	FALSE
GT2	HNOS4	-14.208	1.100	16.408	FALSE
GT2	HW1	-13.208	2.100	17.408	FALSE
GT2	HW2	-11.308	4.000	19.308	FALSE
GT2	LZG	-12.308	3.000	18.308	FALSE
GT2	MTG1	-11.208	4.100	19.408	FALSE
GT2	MTG3	-10.808	4.500	19.808	FALSE
GT2	MTG4	-10.008	5.300	20.608	FALSE
GT2	MTG5	-10.308	5.000	20.308	FALSE
GT2	RCJ1	-10.808	4.500	19.808	FALSE
GT2	RCJ3	-10.208	5.100	20.408	FALSE
GT2	RCJ4	-8.108	7.200	22.508	FALSE
GT2	RK1	-6.008	9.300	24.608	FALSE
GT2	SS	-6.108	9.200	24.508	FALSE
GT2	TTOS	-0.708	14.600	29.908	FALSE
GT2	VA1	-6.208	9.100	24.408	FALSE
GT2	VA2	0.992	16.300	31.608	TRUE
GT2	XLZZG	0.792	16.100	31.408	TRUE
GT2	XZZ	-0.608	14.700	30.008	FALSE
HNOS1	HNOS2	-15.008	0.300	15.608	FALSE
HNOS1	HNOS3	-14.608	0.700	16.008	FALSE
HNOS1	HNOS4	-13.608	1.700	17.008	FALSE
HNOS1	HW1	-12.608	2.700	18.008	FALSE
HNOS1	HW2	-10.708	4.600	19.908	FALSE
HNOS1	LZG	-11.708	3.600	18.908	FALSE
HNOS1	MTG1	-10.608	4.700	20.008	FALSE
HNOS1	MTG3	-10.208	5.100	20.408	FALSE
HNOS1	MTG4	-9.408	5.900	21.208	FALSE
HNOS1	MTG5	-9.708	5.600	20.908	FALSE
HNOS1	RCJ1	-10.208	5.100	20.408	FALSE
HNOS1	RCJ3	-9.608	5.700	21.008	FALSE
HNOS1	RCJ4	-7.508	7.800	23.108	FALSE
HNOS1	RK1	-5.408	9.900	25.208	FALSE
HNOS1	SS	-5.508	9.800	25.108	FALSE
HNOS1	TTOS	-0.108	15.200	30.508	FALSE
HNOS1	VA1	-5.608	9.700	25.008	FALSE
HNOS1	VA2	1.592	16.900	32.208	TRUE
HNOS1	XLZZG	1.392	16.700	32.008	TRUE
HNOS1	XZZ	-0.008	15.300	30.608	FALSE
HNOS2	HNOS3	-14.908	0.400	15.708	FALSE
HNOS2	HNOS4	-13.908	1.400	16.708	FALSE
HNOS2	HW1	-12.908	2.400	17.708	FALSE
HNOS2	HW2	-11.008	4.300	19.608	FALSE
HNOS2	LZG	-12.008	3.300	18.608	FALSE
HNOS2	MTG1	-10.908	4.400	19.708	FALSE
HNOS2	MTG3	-10.508	4.800	20.108	FALSE
HNOS2	MTG4	-9.708	5.600	20.908	FALSE
HNOS2	MTG5	-10.008	5.300	20.608	FALSE
HNOS2	RCJ1	-10.508	4.800	20.108	FALSE
HNOS2	RCJ3	-9.908	5.400	20.708	FALSE
HNOS2	RCJ4	-7.808	7.500	22.808	FALSE
HNOS2	RK1	-5.708	9.600	24.908	FALSE
HNOS2	SS	-5.808	9.500	24.808	FALSE
HNOS2	TTOS	-0.408	14.900	30.208	FALSE
HNOS2	VA1	-5.908	9.400	24.708	FALSE
HNOS2	VA2	1.292	16.600	31.908	TRUE
HNOS2	XLZZG	1.092	16.400	31.708	TRUE
HNOS2	XZZ	-0.308	15.000	30.308	FALSE
HNOS3	HNOS4	-14.308	1.000	16.308	FALSE
HNOS3	HW1	-13.308	2.000	17.308	FALSE
HNOS3	HW2	-11.408	3.900	19.208	FALSE
HNOS3	LZG	-12.408	2.900	18.208	FALSE
HNOS3	MTG1	-11.308	4.000	19.308	FALSE
HNOS3	MTG3	-10.908	4.400	19.708	FALSE
HNOS3	MTG4	-10.108	5.200	20.508	FALSE
HNOS3	MTG5	-10.408	4.900	20.208	FALSE
HNOS3	RCJ1	-10.908	4.400	19.708	FALSE
HNOS3	RCJ3	-10.308	5.000	20.308	FALSE
HNOS3	RCJ4	-8.208	7.100	22.408	FALSE
HNOS3	RK1	-6.108	9.200	24.508	FALSE
HNOS3	SS	-6.208	9.100	24.408	FALSE
HNOS3	TTOS	-0.808	14.500	29.808	FALSE
HNOS3	VA1	-6.308	9.000	24.308	FALSE
HNOS3	VA2	0.892	16.200	31.508	TRUE
HNOS3	XLZZG	0.692	16.000	31.308	TRUE
HNOS3	XZZ	-0.708	14.600	29.908	FALSE
HNOS4	HW1	-14.308	1.000	16.308	FALSE
HNOS4	HW2	-12.408	2.900	18.208	FALSE
HNOS4	LZG	-13.408	1.900	17.208	FALSE
HNOS4	MTG1	-12.308	3.000	18.308	FALSE
HNOS4	MTG3	-11.908	3.400	18.708	FALSE
HNOS4	MTG4	-11.108	4.200	19.508	FALSE
HNOS4	MTG5	-11.408	3.900	19.208	FALSE
HNOS4	RCJ1	-11.908	3.400	18.708	FALSE
HNOS4	RCJ3	-11.308	4.000	19.308	FALSE
HNOS4	RCJ4	-9.208	6.100	21.408	FALSE
HNOS4	RK1	-7.108	8.200	23.508	FALSE
HNOS4	SS	-7.208	8.100	23.408	FALSE
HNOS4	TTOS	-1.808	13.500	28.808	FALSE
HNOS4	VA1	-7.308	8.000	23.308	FALSE
HNOS4	VA2	-0.108	15.200	30.508	FALSE
HNOS4	XLZZG	-0.308	15.000	30.308	FALSE
HNOS4	XZZ	-1.708	13.600	28.908	FALSE
HW1	HW2	-13.408	1.900	17.208	FALSE
HW1	LZG	-14.408	0.900	16.208	FALSE
HW1	MTG1	-13.308	2.000	17.308	FALSE
HW1	MTG3	-12.908	2.400	17.708	FALSE
HW1	MTG4	-12.108	3.200	18.508	FALSE
HW1	MTG5	-12.408	2.900	18.208	FALSE
HW1	RCJ1	-12.908	2.400	17.708	FALSE
HW1	RCJ3	-12.308	3.000	18.308	FALSE
HW1	RCJ4	-10.208	5.100	20.408	FALSE
HW1	RK1	-8.108	7.200	22.508	FALSE
HW1	SS	-8.208	7.100	22.408	FALSE
HW1	TTOS	-2.808	12.500	27.808	FALSE
HW1	VA1	-8.308	7.000	22.308	FALSE
HW1	VA2	-1.108	14.200	29.508	FALSE
HW1	XLZZG	-1.308	14.000	29.308	FALSE
HW1	XZZ	-2.708	12.600	27.908	FALSE
HW2	LZG	-16.308	-1.000	14.308	FALSE
HW2	MTG1	-15.208	0.100	15.408	FALSE
HW2	MTG3	-14.808	0.500	15.808	FALSE
HW2	MTG4	-14.008	1.300	16.608	FALSE
HW2	MTG5	-14.308	1.000	16.308	FALSE
HW2	RCJ1	-14.808	0.500	15.808	FALSE
HW2	RCJ3	-14.208	1.100	16.408	FALSE
HW2	RCJ4	-12.108	3.200	18.508	FALSE
HW2	RK1	-10.008	5.300	20.608	FALSE
HW2	SS	-10.108	5.200	20.508	FALSE
HW2	TTOS	-4.708	10.600	25.908	FALSE
HW2	VA1	-10.208	5.100	20.408	FALSE
HW2	VA2	-3.008	12.300	27.608	FALSE
HW2	XLZZG	-3.208	12.100	27.408	FALSE
HW2	XZZ	-4.608	10.700	26.008	FALSE
LZG	MTG1	-14.208	1.100	16.408	FALSE
LZG	MTG3	-13.808	1.500	16.808	FALSE
LZG	MTG4	-13.008	2.300	17.608	FALSE
LZG	MTG5	-13.308	2.000	17.308	FALSE
LZG	RCJ1	-13.808	1.500	16.808	FALSE
LZG	RCJ3	-13.208	2.100	17.408	FALSE
LZG	RCJ4	-11.108	4.200	19.508	FALSE
LZG	RK1	-9.008	6.300	21.608	FALSE
LZG	SS	-9.108	6.200	21.508	FALSE
LZG	TTOS	-3.708	11.600	26.908	FALSE
LZG	VA1	-9.208	6.100	21.408	FALSE
LZG	VA2	-2.008	13.300	28.608	FALSE
LZG	XLZZG	-2.208	13.100	28.408	FALSE
LZG	XZZ	-3.608	11.700	27.008	FALSE
MTG1	MTG3	-14.908	0.400	15.708	FALSE
MTG1	MTG4	-14.108	1.200	16.508	FALSE
MTG1	MTG5	-14.408	0.900	16.208	FALSE
MTG1	RCJ1	-14.908	0.400	15.708	FALSE
MTG1	RCJ3	-14.308	1.000	16.308	FALSE
MTG1	RCJ4	-12.208	3.100	18.408	FALSE
MTG1	RK1	-10.108	5.200	20.508	FALSE
MTG1	SS	-10.208	5.100	20.408	FALSE
MTG1	TTOS	-4.808	10.500	25.808	FALSE
MTG1	VA1	-10.308	5.000	20.308	FALSE
MTG1	VA2	-3.108	12.200	27.508	FALSE
MTG1	XLZZG	-3.308	12.000	27.308	FALSE
MTG1	XZZ	-4.708	10.600	25.908	FALSE
MTG3	MTG4	-14.508	0.800	16.108	FALSE
MTG3	MTG5	-14.808	0.500	15.808	FALSE
MTG3	RCJ1	-15.308	0.000	15.308	FALSE
MTG3	RCJ3	-14.708	0.600	15.908	FALSE
MTG3	RCJ4	-12.608	2.700	18.008	FALSE
MTG3	RK1	-10.508	4.800	20.108	FALSE
MTG3	SS	-10.608	4.700	20.008	FALSE
MTG3	TTOS	-5.208	10.100	25.408	FALSE
MTG3	VA1	-10.708	4.600	19.908	FALSE
MTG3	VA2	-3.508	11.800	27.108	FALSE
MTG3	XLZZG	-3.708	11.600	26.908	FALSE
MTG3	XZZ	-5.108	10.200	25.508	FALSE
MTG4	MTG5	-15.608	-0.300	15.008	FALSE
MTG4	RCJ1	-16.108	-0.800	14.508	FALSE
MTG4	RCJ3	-15.508	-0.200	15.108	FALSE
MTG4	RCJ4	-13.408	1.900	17.208	FALSE
MTG4	RK1	-11.308	4.000	19.308	FALSE
MTG4	SS	-11.408	3.900	19.208	FALSE
MTG4	TTOS	-6.008	9.300	24.608	FALSE
MTG4	VA1	-11.508	3.800	19.108	FALSE
MTG4	VA2	-4.308	11.000	26.308	FALSE
MTG4	XLZZG	-4.508	10.800	26.108	FALSE
MTG4	XZZ	-5.908	9.400	24.708	FALSE
MTG5	RCJ1	-15.808	-0.500	14.808	FALSE
MTG5	RCJ3	-15.208	0.100	15.408	FALSE
MTG5	RCJ4	-13.108	2.200	17.508	FALSE
MTG5	RK1	-11.008	4.300	19.608	FALSE
MTG5	SS	-11.108	4.200	19.508	FALSE
MTG5	TTOS	-5.708	9.600	24.908	FALSE
MTG5	VA1	-11.208	4.100	19.408	FALSE
MTG5	VA2	-4.008	11.300	26.608	FALSE
MTG5	XLZZG	-4.208	11.100	26.408	FALSE
MTG5	XZZ	-5.608	9.700	25.008	FALSE
RCJ1	RCJ3	-14.708	0.600	15.908	FALSE
RCJ1	RCJ4	-12.608	2.700	18.008	FALSE
RCJ1	RK1	-10.508	4.800	20.108	FALSE
RCJ1	SS	-10.608	4.700	20.008	FALSE
RCJ1	TTOS	-5.208	10.100	25.408	FALSE
RCJ1	VA1	-10.708	4.600	19.908	FALSE
RCJ1	VA2	-3.508	11.800	27.108	FALSE
RCJ1	XLZZG	-3.708	11.600	26.908	FALSE
RCJ1	XZZ	-5.108	10.200	25.508	FALSE
RCJ3	RCJ4	-13.208	2.100	17.408	FALSE
RCJ3	RK1	-11.108	4.200	19.508	FALSE
RCJ3	SS	-11.208	4.100	19.408	FALSE
RCJ3	TTOS	-5.808	9.500	24.808	FALSE
RCJ3	VA1	-11.308	4.000	19.308	FALSE
RCJ3	VA2	-4.108	11.200	26.508	FALSE
RCJ3	XLZZG	-4.308	11.000	26.308	FALSE
RCJ3	XZZ	-5.708	9.600	24.908	FALSE
RCJ4	RK1	-13.208	2.100	17.408	FALSE
RCJ4	SS	-13.308	2.000	17.308	FALSE
RCJ4	TTOS	-7.908	7.400	22.708	FALSE
RCJ4	VA1	-13.408	1.900	17.208	FALSE
RCJ4	VA2	-6.208	9.100	24.408	FALSE
RCJ4	XLZZG	-6.408	8.900	24.208	FALSE
RCJ4	XZZ	-7.808	7.500	22.808	FALSE
RK1	SS	-15.408	-0.100	15.208	FALSE
RK1	TTOS	-10.008	5.300	20.608	FALSE
RK1	VA1	-15.508	-0.200	15.108	FALSE
RK1	VA2	-8.308	7.000	22.308	FALSE
RK1	XLZZG	-8.508	6.800	22.108	FALSE
RK1	XZZ	-9.908	5.400	20.708	FALSE
SS	TTOS	-9.908	5.400	20.708	FALSE
SS	VA1	-15.408	-0.100	15.208	FALSE
SS	VA2	-8.208	7.100	22.408	FALSE
SS	XLZZG	-8.408	6.900	22.208	FALSE
SS	XZZ	-9.808	5.500	20.808	FALSE
TTOS	VA1	-20.808	-5.500	9.808	FALSE
TTOS	VA2	-13.608	1.700	17.008	FALSE
TTOS	XLZZG	-13.808	1.500	16.808	FALSE
TTOS	XZZ	-15.208	0.100	15.408	FALSE
VA1	VA2	-8.108	7.200	22.508	FALSE
VA1	XLZZG	-8.308	7.000	22.308	FALSE
VA1	XZZ	-9.708	5.600	20.908	FALSE
VA2	XLZZG	-15.508	-0.200	15.108	FALSE
VA2	XZZ	-16.908	-1.600	13.708	FALSE
XLZZG	XZZ	-16.708	-1.400	13.908	FALSE

download these results as csv

https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/small.audiogenre_Accuracy_Per_Class.friedman.tukeyKramerHSD.png

Folds vs. Systems Tukey-Kramer HSD Multi-Comparison

The Friedman test was run in MATLAB against the accuracy for each fold. The Tukey-Kramer HSD multi-comparison data below was generated using the following MATLAB instruction. Command:
[c, m, h, gnames] = multicompare(stats, 'ctype', 'tukey-kramer', 'estimate', 'friedman', 'alpha', 0.05);

TeamID	TeamID	Lowerbound	Mean	Upperbound	Significance
ANO	BP1	-28.277	-0.333	27.611	FALSE
ANO	BP2	-26.277	1.667	29.611	FALSE
ANO	CL1	-25.277	2.667	30.611	FALSE
ANO	CL2	-24.611	3.333	31.277	FALSE
ANO	GLR1	-23.111	4.833	32.777	FALSE
ANO	GLR2	-21.944	6.000	33.944	FALSE
ANO	GP	-21.444	6.500	34.444	FALSE
ANO	GT1	-20.444	7.500	35.444	FALSE
ANO	GT2	-18.777	9.167	37.111	FALSE
ANO	HNOS1	-18.944	9.000	36.944	FALSE
ANO	HNOS2	-19.277	8.667	36.611	FALSE
ANO	HNOS3	-16.277	11.667	39.611	FALSE
ANO	HNOS4	-15.611	12.333	40.277	FALSE
ANO	HW1	-13.611	14.333	42.277	FALSE
ANO	HW2	-10.611	17.333	45.277	FALSE
ANO	LZG	-12.944	15.000	42.944	FALSE
ANO	MTG1	-11.277	16.667	44.611	FALSE
ANO	MTG3	-10.611	17.333	45.277	FALSE
ANO	MTG4	-9.611	18.333	46.277	FALSE
ANO	MTG5	-10.277	17.667	45.611	FALSE
ANO	RCJ1	-8.944	19.000	46.944	FALSE
ANO	RCJ3	-8.944	19.000	46.944	FALSE
ANO	RCJ4	-5.277	22.667	50.611	FALSE
ANO	RK1	-4.611	23.333	51.277	FALSE
ANO	SS	-3.944	24.000	51.944	FALSE
ANO	TTOS	-2.611	25.333	53.277	FALSE
ANO	VA1	-1.611	26.333	54.277	FALSE
ANO	VA2	-0.611	27.333	55.277	FALSE
ANO	XLZZG	0.389	28.333	56.277	TRUE
ANO	XZZ	1.389	29.333	57.277	TRUE
BP1	BP2	-25.944	2.000	29.944	FALSE
BP1	CL1	-24.944	3.000	30.944	FALSE
BP1	CL2	-24.277	3.667	31.611	FALSE
BP1	GLR1	-22.777	5.167	33.111	FALSE
BP1	GLR2	-21.611	6.333	34.277	FALSE
BP1	GP	-21.111	6.833	34.777	FALSE
BP1	GT1	-20.111	7.833	35.777	FALSE
BP1	GT2	-18.444	9.500	37.444	FALSE
BP1	HNOS1	-18.611	9.333	37.277	FALSE
BP1	HNOS2	-18.944	9.000	36.944	FALSE
BP1	HNOS3	-15.944	12.000	39.944	FALSE
BP1	HNOS4	-15.277	12.667	40.611	FALSE
BP1	HW1	-13.277	14.667	42.611	FALSE
BP1	HW2	-10.277	17.667	45.611	FALSE
BP1	LZG	-12.611	15.333	43.277	FALSE
BP1	MTG1	-10.944	17.000	44.944	FALSE
BP1	MTG3	-10.277	17.667	45.611	FALSE
BP1	MTG4	-9.277	18.667	46.611	FALSE
BP1	MTG5	-9.944	18.000	45.944	FALSE
BP1	RCJ1	-8.611	19.333	47.277	FALSE
BP1	RCJ3	-8.611	19.333	47.277	FALSE
BP1	RCJ4	-4.944	23.000	50.944	FALSE
BP1	RK1	-4.277	23.667	51.611	FALSE
BP1	SS	-3.611	24.333	52.277	FALSE
BP1	TTOS	-2.277	25.667	53.611	FALSE
BP1	VA1	-1.277	26.667	54.611	FALSE
BP1	VA2	-0.277	27.667	55.611	FALSE
BP1	XLZZG	0.723	28.667	56.611	TRUE
BP1	XZZ	1.723	29.667	57.611	TRUE
BP2	CL1	-26.944	1.000	28.944	FALSE
BP2	CL2	-26.277	1.667	29.611	FALSE
BP2	GLR1	-24.777	3.167	31.111	FALSE
BP2	GLR2	-23.611	4.333	32.277	FALSE
BP2	GP	-23.111	4.833	32.777	FALSE
BP2	GT1	-22.111	5.833	33.777	FALSE
BP2	GT2	-20.444	7.500	35.444	FALSE
BP2	HNOS1	-20.611	7.333	35.277	FALSE
BP2	HNOS2	-20.944	7.000	34.944	FALSE
BP2	HNOS3	-17.944	10.000	37.944	FALSE
BP2	HNOS4	-17.277	10.667	38.611	FALSE
BP2	HW1	-15.277	12.667	40.611	FALSE
BP2	HW2	-12.277	15.667	43.611	FALSE
BP2	LZG	-14.611	13.333	41.277	FALSE
BP2	MTG1	-12.944	15.000	42.944	FALSE
BP2	MTG3	-12.277	15.667	43.611	FALSE
BP2	MTG4	-11.277	16.667	44.611	FALSE
BP2	MTG5	-11.944	16.000	43.944	FALSE
BP2	RCJ1	-10.611	17.333	45.277	FALSE
BP2	RCJ3	-10.611	17.333	45.277	FALSE
BP2	RCJ4	-6.944	21.000	48.944	FALSE
BP2	RK1	-6.277	21.667	49.611	FALSE
BP2	SS	-5.611	22.333	50.277	FALSE
BP2	TTOS	-4.277	23.667	51.611	FALSE
BP2	VA1	-3.277	24.667	52.611	FALSE
BP2	VA2	-2.277	25.667	53.611	FALSE
BP2	XLZZG	-1.277	26.667	54.611	FALSE
BP2	XZZ	-0.277	27.667	55.611	FALSE
CL1	CL2	-27.277	0.667	28.611	FALSE
CL1	GLR1	-25.777	2.167	30.111	FALSE
CL1	GLR2	-24.611	3.333	31.277	FALSE
CL1	GP	-24.111	3.833	31.777	FALSE
CL1	GT1	-23.111	4.833	32.777	FALSE
CL1	GT2	-21.444	6.500	34.444	FALSE
CL1	HNOS1	-21.611	6.333	34.277	FALSE
CL1	HNOS2	-21.944	6.000	33.944	FALSE
CL1	HNOS3	-18.944	9.000	36.944	FALSE
CL1	HNOS4	-18.277	9.667	37.611	FALSE
CL1	HW1	-16.277	11.667	39.611	FALSE
CL1	HW2	-13.277	14.667	42.611	FALSE
CL1	LZG	-15.611	12.333	40.277	FALSE
CL1	MTG1	-13.944	14.000	41.944	FALSE
CL1	MTG3	-13.277	14.667	42.611	FALSE
CL1	MTG4	-12.277	15.667	43.611	FALSE
CL1	MTG5	-12.944	15.000	42.944	FALSE
CL1	RCJ1	-11.611	16.333	44.277	FALSE
CL1	RCJ3	-11.611	16.333	44.277	FALSE
CL1	RCJ4	-7.944	20.000	47.944	FALSE
CL1	RK1	-7.277	20.667	48.611	FALSE
CL1	SS	-6.611	21.333	49.277	FALSE
CL1	TTOS	-5.277	22.667	50.611	FALSE
CL1	VA1	-4.277	23.667	51.611	FALSE
CL1	VA2	-3.277	24.667	52.611	FALSE
CL1	XLZZG	-2.277	25.667	53.611	FALSE
CL1	XZZ	-1.277	26.667	54.611	FALSE
CL2	GLR1	-26.444	1.500	29.444	FALSE
CL2	GLR2	-25.277	2.667	30.611	FALSE
CL2	GP	-24.777	3.167	31.111	FALSE
CL2	GT1	-23.777	4.167	32.111	FALSE
CL2	GT2	-22.111	5.833	33.777	FALSE
CL2	HNOS1	-22.277	5.667	33.611	FALSE
CL2	HNOS2	-22.611	5.333	33.277	FALSE
CL2	HNOS3	-19.611	8.333	36.277	FALSE
CL2	HNOS4	-18.944	9.000	36.944	FALSE
CL2	HW1	-16.944	11.000	38.944	FALSE
CL2	HW2	-13.944	14.000	41.944	FALSE
CL2	LZG	-16.277	11.667	39.611	FALSE
CL2	MTG1	-14.611	13.333	41.277	FALSE
CL2	MTG3	-13.944	14.000	41.944	FALSE
CL2	MTG4	-12.944	15.000	42.944	FALSE
CL2	MTG5	-13.611	14.333	42.277	FALSE
CL2	RCJ1	-12.277	15.667	43.611	FALSE
CL2	RCJ3	-12.277	15.667	43.611	FALSE
CL2	RCJ4	-8.611	19.333	47.277	FALSE
CL2	RK1	-7.944	20.000	47.944	FALSE
CL2	SS	-7.277	20.667	48.611	FALSE
CL2	TTOS	-5.944	22.000	49.944	FALSE
CL2	VA1	-4.944	23.000	50.944	FALSE
CL2	VA2	-3.944	24.000	51.944	FALSE
CL2	XLZZG	-2.944	25.000	52.944	FALSE
CL2	XZZ	-1.944	26.000	53.944	FALSE
GLR1	GLR2	-26.777	1.167	29.111	FALSE
GLR1	GP	-26.277	1.667	29.611	FALSE
GLR1	GT1	-25.277	2.667	30.611	FALSE
GLR1	GT2	-23.611	4.333	32.277	FALSE
GLR1	HNOS1	-23.777	4.167	32.111	FALSE
GLR1	HNOS2	-24.111	3.833	31.777	FALSE
GLR1	HNOS3	-21.111	6.833	34.777	FALSE
GLR1	HNOS4	-20.444	7.500	35.444	FALSE
GLR1	HW1	-18.444	9.500	37.444	FALSE
GLR1	HW2	-15.444	12.500	40.444	FALSE
GLR1	LZG	-17.777	10.167	38.111	FALSE
GLR1	MTG1	-16.111	11.833	39.777	FALSE
GLR1	MTG3	-15.444	12.500	40.444	FALSE
GLR1	MTG4	-14.444	13.500	41.444	FALSE
GLR1	MTG5	-15.111	12.833	40.777	FALSE
GLR1	RCJ1	-13.777	14.167	42.111	FALSE
GLR1	RCJ3	-13.777	14.167	42.111	FALSE
GLR1	RCJ4	-10.111	17.833	45.777	FALSE
GLR1	RK1	-9.444	18.500	46.444	FALSE
GLR1	SS	-8.777	19.167	47.111	FALSE
GLR1	TTOS	-7.444	20.500	48.444	FALSE
GLR1	VA1	-6.444	21.500	49.444	FALSE
GLR1	VA2	-5.444	22.500	50.444	FALSE
GLR1	XLZZG	-4.444	23.500	51.444	FALSE
GLR1	XZZ	-3.444	24.500	52.444	FALSE
GLR2	GP	-27.444	0.500	28.444	FALSE
GLR2	GT1	-26.444	1.500	29.444	FALSE
GLR2	GT2	-24.777	3.167	31.111	FALSE
GLR2	HNOS1	-24.944	3.000	30.944	FALSE
GLR2	HNOS2	-25.277	2.667	30.611	FALSE
GLR2	HNOS3	-22.277	5.667	33.611	FALSE
GLR2	HNOS4	-21.611	6.333	34.277	FALSE
GLR2	HW1	-19.611	8.333	36.277	FALSE
GLR2	HW2	-16.611	11.333	39.277	FALSE
GLR2	LZG	-18.944	9.000	36.944	FALSE
GLR2	MTG1	-17.277	10.667	38.611	FALSE
GLR2	MTG3	-16.611	11.333	39.277	FALSE
GLR2	MTG4	-15.611	12.333	40.277	FALSE
GLR2	MTG5	-16.277	11.667	39.611	FALSE
GLR2	RCJ1	-14.944	13.000	40.944	FALSE
GLR2	RCJ3	-14.944	13.000	40.944	FALSE
GLR2	RCJ4	-11.277	16.667	44.611	FALSE
GLR2	RK1	-10.611	17.333	45.277	FALSE
GLR2	SS	-9.944	18.000	45.944	FALSE
GLR2	TTOS	-8.611	19.333	47.277	FALSE
GLR2	VA1	-7.611	20.333	48.277	FALSE
GLR2	VA2	-6.611	21.333	49.277	FALSE
GLR2	XLZZG	-5.611	22.333	50.277	FALSE
GLR2	XZZ	-4.611	23.333	51.277	FALSE
GP	GT1	-26.944	1.000	28.944	FALSE
GP	GT2	-25.277	2.667	30.611	FALSE
GP	HNOS1	-25.444	2.500	30.444	FALSE
GP	HNOS2	-25.777	2.167	30.111	FALSE
GP	HNOS3	-22.777	5.167	33.111	FALSE
GP	HNOS4	-22.111	5.833	33.777	FALSE
GP	HW1	-20.111	7.833	35.777	FALSE
GP	HW2	-17.111	10.833	38.777	FALSE
GP	LZG	-19.444	8.500	36.444	FALSE
GP	MTG1	-17.777	10.167	38.111	FALSE
GP	MTG3	-17.111	10.833	38.777	FALSE
GP	MTG4	-16.111	11.833	39.777	FALSE
GP	MTG5	-16.777	11.167	39.111	FALSE
GP	RCJ1	-15.444	12.500	40.444	FALSE
GP	RCJ3	-15.444	12.500	40.444	FALSE
GP	RCJ4	-11.777	16.167	44.111	FALSE
GP	RK1	-11.111	16.833	44.777	FALSE
GP	SS	-10.444	17.500	45.444	FALSE
GP	TTOS	-9.111	18.833	46.777	FALSE
GP	VA1	-8.111	19.833	47.777	FALSE
GP	VA2	-7.111	20.833	48.777	FALSE
GP	XLZZG	-6.111	21.833	49.777	FALSE
GP	XZZ	-5.111	22.833	50.777	FALSE
GT1	GT2	-26.277	1.667	29.611	FALSE
GT1	HNOS1	-26.444	1.500	29.444	FALSE
GT1	HNOS2	-26.777	1.167	29.111	FALSE
GT1	HNOS3	-23.777	4.167	32.111	FALSE
GT1	HNOS4	-23.111	4.833	32.777	FALSE
GT1	HW1	-21.111	6.833	34.777	FALSE
GT1	HW2	-18.111	9.833	37.777	FALSE
GT1	LZG	-20.444	7.500	35.444	FALSE
GT1	MTG1	-18.777	9.167	37.111	FALSE
GT1	MTG3	-18.111	9.833	37.777	FALSE
GT1	MTG4	-17.111	10.833	38.777	FALSE
GT1	MTG5	-17.777	10.167	38.111	FALSE
GT1	RCJ1	-16.444	11.500	39.444	FALSE
GT1	RCJ3	-16.444	11.500	39.444	FALSE
GT1	RCJ4	-12.777	15.167	43.111	FALSE
GT1	RK1	-12.111	15.833	43.777	FALSE
GT1	SS	-11.444	16.500	44.444	FALSE
GT1	TTOS	-10.111	17.833	45.777	FALSE
GT1	VA1	-9.111	18.833	46.777	FALSE
GT1	VA2	-8.111	19.833	47.777	FALSE
GT1	XLZZG	-7.111	20.833	48.777	FALSE
GT1	XZZ	-6.111	21.833	49.777	FALSE
GT2	HNOS1	-28.111	-0.167	27.777	FALSE
GT2	HNOS2	-28.444	-0.500	27.444	FALSE
GT2	HNOS3	-25.444	2.500	30.444	FALSE
GT2	HNOS4	-24.777	3.167	31.111	FALSE
GT2	HW1	-22.777	5.167	33.111	FALSE
GT2	HW2	-19.777	8.167	36.111	FALSE
GT2	LZG	-22.111	5.833	33.777	FALSE
GT2	MTG1	-20.444	7.500	35.444	FALSE
GT2	MTG3	-19.777	8.167	36.111	FALSE
GT2	MTG4	-18.777	9.167	37.111	FALSE
GT2	MTG5	-19.444	8.500	36.444	FALSE
GT2	RCJ1	-18.111	9.833	37.777	FALSE
GT2	RCJ3	-18.111	9.833	37.777	FALSE
GT2	RCJ4	-14.444	13.500	41.444	FALSE
GT2	RK1	-13.777	14.167	42.111	FALSE
GT2	SS	-13.111	14.833	42.777	FALSE
GT2	TTOS	-11.777	16.167	44.111	FALSE
GT2	VA1	-10.777	17.167	45.111	FALSE
GT2	VA2	-9.777	18.167	46.111	FALSE
GT2	XLZZG	-8.777	19.167	47.111	FALSE
GT2	XZZ	-7.777	20.167	48.111	FALSE
HNOS1	HNOS2	-28.277	-0.333	27.611	FALSE
HNOS1	HNOS3	-25.277	2.667	30.611	FALSE
HNOS1	HNOS4	-24.611	3.333	31.277	FALSE
HNOS1	HW1	-22.611	5.333	33.277	FALSE
HNOS1	HW2	-19.611	8.333	36.277	FALSE
HNOS1	LZG	-21.944	6.000	33.944	FALSE
HNOS1	MTG1	-20.277	7.667	35.611	FALSE
HNOS1	MTG3	-19.611	8.333	36.277	FALSE
HNOS1	MTG4	-18.611	9.333	37.277	FALSE
HNOS1	MTG5	-19.277	8.667	36.611	FALSE
HNOS1	RCJ1	-17.944	10.000	37.944	FALSE
HNOS1	RCJ3	-17.944	10.000	37.944	FALSE
HNOS1	RCJ4	-14.277	13.667	41.611	FALSE
HNOS1	RK1	-13.611	14.333	42.277	FALSE
HNOS1	SS	-12.944	15.000	42.944	FALSE
HNOS1	TTOS	-11.611	16.333	44.277	FALSE
HNOS1	VA1	-10.611	17.333	45.277	FALSE
HNOS1	VA2	-9.611	18.333	46.277	FALSE
HNOS1	XLZZG	-8.611	19.333	47.277	FALSE
HNOS1	XZZ	-7.611	20.333	48.277	FALSE
HNOS2	HNOS3	-24.944	3.000	30.944	FALSE
HNOS2	HNOS4	-24.277	3.667	31.611	FALSE
HNOS2	HW1	-22.277	5.667	33.611	FALSE
HNOS2	HW2	-19.277	8.667	36.611	FALSE
HNOS2	LZG	-21.611	6.333	34.277	FALSE
HNOS2	MTG1	-19.944	8.000	35.944	FALSE
HNOS2	MTG3	-19.277	8.667	36.611	FALSE
HNOS2	MTG4	-18.277	9.667	37.611	FALSE
HNOS2	MTG5	-18.944	9.000	36.944	FALSE
HNOS2	RCJ1	-17.611	10.333	38.277	FALSE
HNOS2	RCJ3	-17.611	10.333	38.277	FALSE
HNOS2	RCJ4	-13.944	14.000	41.944	FALSE
HNOS2	RK1	-13.277	14.667	42.611	FALSE
HNOS2	SS	-12.611	15.333	43.277	FALSE
HNOS2	TTOS	-11.277	16.667	44.611	FALSE
HNOS2	VA1	-10.277	17.667	45.611	FALSE
HNOS2	VA2	-9.277	18.667	46.611	FALSE
HNOS2	XLZZG	-8.277	19.667	47.611	FALSE
HNOS2	XZZ	-7.277	20.667	48.611	FALSE
HNOS3	HNOS4	-27.277	0.667	28.611	FALSE
HNOS3	HW1	-25.277	2.667	30.611	FALSE
HNOS3	HW2	-22.277	5.667	33.611	FALSE
HNOS3	LZG	-24.611	3.333	31.277	FALSE
HNOS3	MTG1	-22.944	5.000	32.944	FALSE
HNOS3	MTG3	-22.277	5.667	33.611	FALSE
HNOS3	MTG4	-21.277	6.667	34.611	FALSE
HNOS3	MTG5	-21.944	6.000	33.944	FALSE
HNOS3	RCJ1	-20.611	7.333	35.277	FALSE
HNOS3	RCJ3	-20.611	7.333	35.277	FALSE
HNOS3	RCJ4	-16.944	11.000	38.944	FALSE
HNOS3	RK1	-16.277	11.667	39.611	FALSE
HNOS3	SS	-15.611	12.333	40.277	FALSE
HNOS3	TTOS	-14.277	13.667	41.611	FALSE
HNOS3	VA1	-13.277	14.667	42.611	FALSE
HNOS3	VA2	-12.277	15.667	43.611	FALSE
HNOS3	XLZZG	-11.277	16.667	44.611	FALSE
HNOS3	XZZ	-10.277	17.667	45.611	FALSE
HNOS4	HW1	-25.944	2.000	29.944	FALSE
HNOS4	HW2	-22.944	5.000	32.944	FALSE
HNOS4	LZG	-25.277	2.667	30.611	FALSE
HNOS4	MTG1	-23.611	4.333	32.277	FALSE
HNOS4	MTG3	-22.944	5.000	32.944	FALSE
HNOS4	MTG4	-21.944	6.000	33.944	FALSE
HNOS4	MTG5	-22.611	5.333	33.277	FALSE
HNOS4	RCJ1	-21.277	6.667	34.611	FALSE
HNOS4	RCJ3	-21.277	6.667	34.611	FALSE
HNOS4	RCJ4	-17.611	10.333	38.277	FALSE
HNOS4	RK1	-16.944	11.000	38.944	FALSE
HNOS4	SS	-16.277	11.667	39.611	FALSE
HNOS4	TTOS	-14.944	13.000	40.944	FALSE
HNOS4	VA1	-13.944	14.000	41.944	FALSE
HNOS4	VA2	-12.944	15.000	42.944	FALSE
HNOS4	XLZZG	-11.944	16.000	43.944	FALSE
HNOS4	XZZ	-10.944	17.000	44.944	FALSE
HW1	HW2	-24.944	3.000	30.944	FALSE
HW1	LZG	-27.277	0.667	28.611	FALSE
HW1	MTG1	-25.611	2.333	30.277	FALSE
HW1	MTG3	-24.944	3.000	30.944	FALSE
HW1	MTG4	-23.944	4.000	31.944	FALSE
HW1	MTG5	-24.611	3.333	31.277	FALSE
HW1	RCJ1	-23.277	4.667	32.611	FALSE
HW1	RCJ3	-23.277	4.667	32.611	FALSE
HW1	RCJ4	-19.611	8.333	36.277	FALSE
HW1	RK1	-18.944	9.000	36.944	FALSE
HW1	SS	-18.277	9.667	37.611	FALSE
HW1	TTOS	-16.944	11.000	38.944	FALSE
HW1	VA1	-15.944	12.000	39.944	FALSE
HW1	VA2	-14.944	13.000	40.944	FALSE
HW1	XLZZG	-13.944	14.000	41.944	FALSE
HW1	XZZ	-12.944	15.000	42.944	FALSE
HW2	LZG	-30.277	-2.333	25.611	FALSE
HW2	MTG1	-28.611	-0.667	27.277	FALSE
HW2	MTG3	-27.944	0.000	27.944	FALSE
HW2	MTG4	-26.944	1.000	28.944	FALSE
HW2	MTG5	-27.611	0.333	28.277	FALSE
HW2	RCJ1	-26.277	1.667	29.611	FALSE
HW2	RCJ3	-26.277	1.667	29.611	FALSE
HW2	RCJ4	-22.611	5.333	33.277	FALSE
HW2	RK1	-21.944	6.000	33.944	FALSE
HW2	SS	-21.277	6.667	34.611	FALSE
HW2	TTOS	-19.944	8.000	35.944	FALSE
HW2	VA1	-18.944	9.000	36.944	FALSE
HW2	VA2	-17.944	10.000	37.944	FALSE
HW2	XLZZG	-16.944	11.000	38.944	FALSE
HW2	XZZ	-15.944	12.000	39.944	FALSE
LZG	MTG1	-26.277	1.667	29.611	FALSE
LZG	MTG3	-25.611	2.333	30.277	FALSE
LZG	MTG4	-24.611	3.333	31.277	FALSE
LZG	MTG5	-25.277	2.667	30.611	FALSE
LZG	RCJ1	-23.944	4.000	31.944	FALSE
LZG	RCJ3	-23.944	4.000	31.944	FALSE
LZG	RCJ4	-20.277	7.667	35.611	FALSE
LZG	RK1	-19.611	8.333	36.277	FALSE
LZG	SS	-18.944	9.000	36.944	FALSE
LZG	TTOS	-17.611	10.333	38.277	FALSE
LZG	VA1	-16.611	11.333	39.277	FALSE
LZG	VA2	-15.611	12.333	40.277	FALSE
LZG	XLZZG	-14.611	13.333	41.277	FALSE
LZG	XZZ	-13.611	14.333	42.277	FALSE
MTG1	MTG3	-27.277	0.667	28.611	FALSE
MTG1	MTG4	-26.277	1.667	29.611	FALSE
MTG1	MTG5	-26.944	1.000	28.944	FALSE
MTG1	RCJ1	-25.611	2.333	30.277	FALSE
MTG1	RCJ3	-25.611	2.333	30.277	FALSE
MTG1	RCJ4	-21.944	6.000	33.944	FALSE
MTG1	RK1	-21.277	6.667	34.611	FALSE
MTG1	SS	-20.611	7.333	35.277	FALSE
MTG1	TTOS	-19.277	8.667	36.611	FALSE
MTG1	VA1	-18.277	9.667	37.611	FALSE
MTG1	VA2	-17.277	10.667	38.611	FALSE
MTG1	XLZZG	-16.277	11.667	39.611	FALSE
MTG1	XZZ	-15.277	12.667	40.611	FALSE
MTG3	MTG4	-26.944	1.000	28.944	FALSE
MTG3	MTG5	-27.611	0.333	28.277	FALSE
MTG3	RCJ1	-26.277	1.667	29.611	FALSE
MTG3	RCJ3	-26.277	1.667	29.611	FALSE
MTG3	RCJ4	-22.611	5.333	33.277	FALSE
MTG3	RK1	-21.944	6.000	33.944	FALSE
MTG3	SS	-21.277	6.667	34.611	FALSE
MTG3	TTOS	-19.944	8.000	35.944	FALSE
MTG3	VA1	-18.944	9.000	36.944	FALSE
MTG3	VA2	-17.944	10.000	37.944	FALSE
MTG3	XLZZG	-16.944	11.000	38.944	FALSE
MTG3	XZZ	-15.944	12.000	39.944	FALSE
MTG4	MTG5	-28.611	-0.667	27.277	FALSE
MTG4	RCJ1	-27.277	0.667	28.611	FALSE
MTG4	RCJ3	-27.277	0.667	28.611	FALSE
MTG4	RCJ4	-23.611	4.333	32.277	FALSE
MTG4	RK1	-22.944	5.000	32.944	FALSE
MTG4	SS	-22.277	5.667	33.611	FALSE
MTG4	TTOS	-20.944	7.000	34.944	FALSE
MTG4	VA1	-19.944	8.000	35.944	FALSE
MTG4	VA2	-18.944	9.000	36.944	FALSE
MTG4	XLZZG	-17.944	10.000	37.944	FALSE
MTG4	XZZ	-16.944	11.000	38.944	FALSE
MTG5	RCJ1	-26.611	1.333	29.277	FALSE
MTG5	RCJ3	-26.611	1.333	29.277	FALSE
MTG5	RCJ4	-22.944	5.000	32.944	FALSE
MTG5	RK1	-22.277	5.667	33.611	FALSE
MTG5	SS	-21.611	6.333	34.277	FALSE
MTG5	TTOS	-20.277	7.667	35.611	FALSE
MTG5	VA1	-19.277	8.667	36.611	FALSE
MTG5	VA2	-18.277	9.667	37.611	FALSE
MTG5	XLZZG	-17.277	10.667	38.611	FALSE
MTG5	XZZ	-16.277	11.667	39.611	FALSE
RCJ1	RCJ3	-27.944	0.000	27.944	FALSE
RCJ1	RCJ4	-24.277	3.667	31.611	FALSE
RCJ1	RK1	-23.611	4.333	32.277	FALSE
RCJ1	SS	-22.944	5.000	32.944	FALSE
RCJ1	TTOS	-21.611	6.333	34.277	FALSE
RCJ1	VA1	-20.611	7.333	35.277	FALSE
RCJ1	VA2	-19.611	8.333	36.277	FALSE
RCJ1	XLZZG	-18.611	9.333	37.277	FALSE
RCJ1	XZZ	-17.611	10.333	38.277	FALSE
RCJ3	RCJ4	-24.277	3.667	31.611	FALSE
RCJ3	RK1	-23.611	4.333	32.277	FALSE
RCJ3	SS	-22.944	5.000	32.944	FALSE
RCJ3	TTOS	-21.611	6.333	34.277	FALSE
RCJ3	VA1	-20.611	7.333	35.277	FALSE
RCJ3	VA2	-19.611	8.333	36.277	FALSE
RCJ3	XLZZG	-18.611	9.333	37.277	FALSE
RCJ3	XZZ	-17.611	10.333	38.277	FALSE
RCJ4	RK1	-27.277	0.667	28.611	FALSE
RCJ4	SS	-26.611	1.333	29.277	FALSE
RCJ4	TTOS	-25.277	2.667	30.611	FALSE
RCJ4	VA1	-24.277	3.667	31.611	FALSE
RCJ4	VA2	-23.277	4.667	32.611	FALSE
RCJ4	XLZZG	-22.277	5.667	33.611	FALSE
RCJ4	XZZ	-21.277	6.667	34.611	FALSE
RK1	SS	-27.277	0.667	28.611	FALSE
RK1	TTOS	-25.944	2.000	29.944	FALSE
RK1	VA1	-24.944	3.000	30.944	FALSE
RK1	VA2	-23.944	4.000	31.944	FALSE
RK1	XLZZG	-22.944	5.000	32.944	FALSE
RK1	XZZ	-21.944	6.000	33.944	FALSE
SS	TTOS	-26.611	1.333	29.277	FALSE
SS	VA1	-25.611	2.333	30.277	FALSE
SS	VA2	-24.611	3.333	31.277	FALSE
SS	XLZZG	-23.611	4.333	32.277	FALSE
SS	XZZ	-22.611	5.333	33.277	FALSE
TTOS	VA1	-26.944	1.000	28.944	FALSE
TTOS	VA2	-25.944	2.000	29.944	FALSE
TTOS	XLZZG	-24.944	3.000	30.944	FALSE
TTOS	XZZ	-23.944	4.000	31.944	FALSE
VA1	VA2	-26.944	1.000	28.944	FALSE
VA1	XLZZG	-25.944	2.000	29.944	FALSE
VA1	XZZ	-24.944	3.000	30.944	FALSE
VA2	XLZZG	-26.944	1.000	28.944	FALSE
VA2	XZZ	-25.944	2.000	29.944	FALSE
XLZZG	XZZ	-26.944	1.000	28.944	FALSE

download these results as csv

https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/small.audiogenre_Accuracy.friedman.tukeyKramerHSD.png

Hierarchical-Discounted Scoring Results

Because of space considerations, the 2009:Mixed Set Hierarchical-Discounted Scoring Results are present on a separate page.

Results By Algorithm

(.tgz)

ANO= Anonymous
BP1= Juan José Burred, Geoffroy Peeters (file)
BP2 = Juan José Burred, Geoffroy Peeters (tw)
CL1 = Chuan Cao, Ming Li
CL2 = Chuan Cao, Ming Li
GP = Geoffroy Peeters
GT1 = George Tzanetakis (mono)
GT2 = George Tzanetakis (stereo)
GLR1 = A. Grecu, T. Lidy, A. Rauber (full)
GLR2 = A. Grecu, T. Lidy, A. Rauber (template)
HNOS1 = Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tcca)
HNOS2 = Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tcck)
HNOS3 = Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tccl)
HNOS4 = Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tcpk)
HW1 = Huaxin Wang
HW2 = Huaxin Wang
VA1 = T. Lidy, A. Grecu, A. Rauber, A. Pertusa, P. J. Ponce de León, J. M. Iñesta (WMV)
VA2 = T. Lidy, A. Grecu, A. Rauber, A. Pertusa, P. J. Ponce de León, J. M. Iñesta (BWWV)
LZG = Yi Liu, Tao Zheng, Yue Gao (RUC_1)
RCJ1 = Jia-Min Ren, Zhi-Sheng Chen, Jyh-Shing Roger Jang
RCJ3 = Jia-Min Ren, Zhi-Sheng Chen, Jyh-Shing Roger Jang
RCJ4 = Jia-Min Ren, Zhi-Sheng Chen, Jyh-Shing Roger Jang
RK1 = Preeti Rao, Sujeet Kini
SS = Klaus Seyerlehner, Markus Schedl
TTOS = Emiru Tsunoo, George Tzanetakis, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama
MTG1 = N. Wack, E. Guaus, C. Laurier, O. Meyers, R. Marxer, D. Bogdanov, J. Serrà, P. Herrera (false, rca)
MTG3 = N. Wack, E. Guaus, C. Laurier, O. Meyers, R. Marxer, D. Bogdanov, J. Serrà, P. Herrera (false, simca)
MTG4 = N. Wack, E. Guaus, C. Laurier, O. Meyers, R. Marxer, D. Bogdanov, J. Serrà, P. Herrera (true, simca)
MTG5 = N. Wack, E. Guaus, C. Laurier, O. Meyers, R. Marxer, D. Bogdanov, J. Serrà, P. Herrera (false, svm)
XLZZG = Jieping Xu, Yi Liu, Tao Zheng, Chao Zhen, Yue Gao (RUC_1)
XZZ = JiePing Xu, Chao Zhen, Tao Zheng (RUC_2)

Run Times

file /nema-raid/www/mirex/results/2009/mood.runtime.csv not found TBA

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
 == Introduction ==
+These are the results for the 2008 running of the Audio Genre Classification (Mixed Set) task. For background information about this task set please refer to the [[2009:Audio Genre Classification]] page.
+'''Mixed Set''' collection statistics: 7000 30-second audio clips in 22.05kHz mono WAV format drawn from 10 genres (700 clips from each genre). Genres:
+* Blues
+* Jazz
+* Country/Western
+* Baroque
+* Classical
+* Romantic
+* Electronica
+* Hip-Hop
+* Rock
+* HardRock/Metal
 === General Legend ===
 ==== Team ID ====
+'''ANO'''= [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/ANO_train_simi.pdf  Anonymous]<br />
+'''BP1'''= [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/BP_train_tag.pdf Juan José Burred, Geoffroy Peeters (file)]<br />
+'''BP2''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/BP_train_tag.pdf Juan José Burred, Geoffroy Peeters (tw)]<br />
+'''CL1''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/CL.pdf Chuan Cao, Ming Li]<br />
+'''CL2''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/CL.pdf Chuan Cao, Ming Li]<br />
+'''GP'''  = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/Peeters_2009_MIREX_classification.pdf Geoffroy Peeters]<br />
+'''GT1''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/GTfinal.pdf George Tzanetakis (mono)]<br />
+'''GT2''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/GTinal.pdf George Tzanetakis (stereo)]<br />
+'''GLR1''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/GLR.pdf Andrei Grecu, Thomas Lidy, Andreas Rauber (full)]<br />
+'''GLR2''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/GLR.pdf  Andrei Grecu, Thomas Lidy, Andreas Rauber (template)]<br />
+'''HNOS1''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/HNOS.pdf Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tcca)]<br />
+'''HNOS2''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/HNOS.pdf Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tcck)]<br />
+'''HNOS3''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/HNOS.pdf Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tccl)]<br />
+'''HNOS4''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/HNOS.pdf Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tcpk)]<br />
+'''HW1'''  = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/HW_train.pdf Huaxin Wang]<br />
+'''HW2'''  = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/HW_train.pdf Huaxin Wang]<br />
+'''VA1''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/VA.pdf  Thomas Lidy,Andrei Grecu, Andreas Rauber, A. Pertusa, Pedro J. Ponce de León, J. M. Iñesta (WMV)]<br />
+'''VA2''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/VA.pdf Thomas Lidy, Andrei Grecu, Andreas Rauber, A. Pertusa, Pedro J. Ponce de León, J. M. Iñesta (BWWV)]<br />
+'''LZG''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/LZG.pdf Yi Liu, Tao Zheng, Yue Gao (RUC_1)]<br />
+'''RCJ1''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/RCJ.pdf Jia-Min Ren, Zhi-Sheng Chen, Jyh-Shing Roger Jang]<br />
+'''RCJ3''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/RCJ.pdf Jia-Min Ren, Zhi-Sheng Chen, Jyh-Shing Roger Jang]<br />
+'''RCJ4''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/RCJ.pdf Jia-Min Ren, Zhi-Sheng Chen, Jyh-Shing Roger Jang]<br />
+'''RK1''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/RK.pdf Preeti Rao, Sujeet Kini]<br />
+'''SS''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/SS.pdf Klaus Seyerlehner, Markus Schedl]<br />
+'''TTOS''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/TTOS_train.pdf Emiru Tsunoo, George Tzanetakis, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama]<br />
+'''MTG1''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/MTG_train.pdf Nicolas Wack, Enric Guaus, Cyril Laurier, Owen Meyers, Ricard Marxer, Dmitry Bogdanov, Joan Serrà, Perfecto Herrera (false, rca)]<br />
+'''MTG3''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/MTG_train.pdf Nicolas Wack, Enric Guaus, Cyril Laurier, Owen Meyers, Ricard Marxer, Dmitry Bogdanov, Joan Serrà, Perfecto Herrera (false, simca)]<br />
+'''MTG4''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/MTG_train.pdf Nicolas Wack, Enric Guaus, Cyril Laurier, Owen Meyers, Ricard Marxer, Dmitry Bogdanov, Joan Serrà, Perfecto Herrera(true, simca)]<br />
+'''MTG5''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/MTG_train.pdf Nicolas Wack, Enric Guaus, Cyril Laurier, Owen Meyers, Ricard Marxer, Dmitry Bogdanov, Joan Serrà, Perfecto Herrera(false, svm)]<br />
+'''XLZZG''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/XLZZG.pdf Jieping Xu, Yi Liu, Tao Zheng, Chao Zhen, Yue Gao (RUC_1)]<br />
+'''XZZ''' = [https://www.music-ir.org/mirex/abstracts/2009/XZZ.pdf JiePing Xu, Chao Zhen, Tao Zheng (RUC_2)]<br />
-'''RK1'''      [[Preeti Rao and Sujeet Kini]]
+==Overall Summary Results==
+===Raw Classification Accuracy Averaged Over Three Train/Test Folds===
-'''RK2'''      [[Preeti Rao and Sujeet Kini]]
-'''HNOS'''     [[Takashi Hasegawa,Takuya Nishimoto,Nobutaka Ono,Shigeki Sagayama]]
-'''HW1'''      [[Huaxin Wang]]
-'''HW2'''      [[Huaxin Wang]]
-'''PE'''       [[Peiszer Ewald]]
-'''LGRPLI'''   [[T.Lidy,A.Grecu,A.Rauber,A.Pertusa,P.J.Ponce de Leon,J.M Inesta]]
-'''LZG'''      [[Yi Liu,Tao Zheng,Yue Gao]]
-'''RCJ1'''     [[Jia-Min Ren,Zhi-Sheng Chen,Jyh-Shing Roger Jang]]
-'''RCJ2'''     [[Jia-Min Ren,Zhi-Sheng Chen,Jyh-Shing Roger Jang]]
-'''RCJ3'''     [[Jia-Min Ren,Zhi-Sheng Chen,Jyh-Shing Roger Jang]]
-'''RCJ4'''     [[Jia-Min Ren,Zhi-Sheng Chen,Jyh-Shing Roger Jang]]
-'''SS'''       [[Klaus Seyerlehner, Markus Schedl]]
+<csv p=3>2009/audiogenre/summary_audiogenre.csv</csv>
-'''TL'''       [[Tsung-Chi Lee]]
+===Accuracy Across Folds===
-'''XLZZG'''     [[Jieping Xu, Yi Liu,Tao Zheng,Chao Zhen,Yue Gao]]
+<csv p=3>2009/audiogenre/audiogenre_Accuracy.csv</csv>
-'''XZZ'''    [[JiePing Xu, Chao Zhen, Tao Zheng]]]
+===Accuracy Across Categories===
-'''GT'''   [[George Tzanetakis]]
+<csv p=3>2009/audiogenre/audiogenre_Accuracy_Per_Class.csv</csv>
-'''GP'''   [[Geoffroy Peeters]]
+==Friedman's Tests for Significant Differences==
+===Classes vs. System Tukey-Kramer HSD Multi-Comparisons ===
+The Friedman test was run in MATLAB against the average accuracy for each class. The Tukey-Kramer HSD multi-comparison data below was generated using the following MATLAB instruction. Command: <br />
+[c, m, h, gnames] = multicompare(stats, 'ctype', 'tukey-kramer', 'estimate', 'friedman', 'alpha', 0.05);
-'''WGLMMBSH''' [[N.Wack,E.Guaus,C.Laurier,O.Meyers,R.Marxer,D.Bogdanov,.Serra,P.Herrera]]
+<csv p=3>2009/audiogenre/audiogenre_Accuracy_Per_Class.friedman.tukeyKramerHSD.csv</csv>
-'''CL1'''    [[Chuan Cao,Ming Li]]
+https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/small.audiogenre_Accuracy_Per_Class.friedman.tukeyKramerHSD.png
-'''CL2'''    [[Chuan Cao,Ming Li]]
+===Folds vs. Systems Tukey-Kramer HSD Multi-Comparison===
+The Friedman test was run in MATLAB against the accuracy for each fold. The Tukey-Kramer HSD multi-comparison data below was generated using the following MATLAB instruction. Command: <br /> [c, m, h, gnames] = multicompare(stats, 'ctype', 'tukey-kramer', 'estimate', 'friedman', 'alpha', 0.05);
-'''AG'''    [[Andrei Grecu]]
+<csv p=3>2009/audiogenre/audiogenre_Accuracy.friedman.tukeyKramerHSD.csv
+</csv>
-'''TF1'''   [[Tao Feng]]
+https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/small.audiogenre_Accuracy.friedman.tukeyKramerHSD.png
-'''TF2'''   [[Tao Feng]]
+==Hierarchical-Discounted Scoring Results==
+Because of space considerations, the [[2009:Mixed Set Hierarchical-Discounted Scoring Results]] are present on a separate page.
-'''BP'''   [[Juan Jose Burred, Geoffroy Peeters]]
+==Results By Algorithm==
+(.tgz) <br />
-'''TAOS''' [[Emiru Tsunoo,Taichi Akase,Nobutaka Ono,Shigeki Sagayama]]
+'''ANO'''= [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/ANO.tgz  Anonymous]<br />
+'''BP1'''= [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/BP1.tgz Juan José Burred, Geoffroy Peeters (file)]<br />
+'''BP2''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/BP2.tgz Juan José Burred, Geoffroy Peeters (tw)]<br />
+'''CL1''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/CL1.tgz Chuan Cao, Ming Li]<br />
+'''CL2''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/CL1.tgz Chuan Cao, Ming Li]<br />
+'''GP'''  = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/GP.tgz Geoffroy Peeters]<br />
+'''GT1''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/GT1.tgz George Tzanetakis (mono)]<br />
+'''GT2''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/GT2.tgz George Tzanetakis (stereo)]<br />
+'''GLR1''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/GLR1.tgz A. Grecu, T. Lidy, A. Rauber (full)]<br />
+'''GLR2''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/GLR2.tgz  A. Grecu, T. Lidy, A. Rauber (template)]<br />
+'''HNOS1''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/HNOS1.tgz Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tcca)]<br />
+'''HNOS2''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/HNOS2.tgz Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tcck)]<br />
+'''HNOS3''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/HNOS3.tgz Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tccl)]<br />
+'''HNOS4''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/HNOS4.tgz Takashi Hasegawa, Takuya Nishimoto, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama (tcpk)]<br />
+'''HW1'''  = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/HW1.tgz Huaxin Wang]<br />
+'''HW2'''  = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/HW2.tgz Huaxin Wang]<br />
+'''VA1''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/VA1.tgz T. Lidy, A. Grecu, A. Rauber, A. Pertusa, P. J. Ponce de León, J. M. Iñesta (WMV)]<br />
+'''VA2''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/VA2.tgz T. Lidy, A. Grecu, A. Rauber, A. Pertusa, P. J. Ponce de León, J. M. Iñesta (BWWV)]<br />
+'''LZG''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/LZG.tgz Yi Liu, Tao Zheng, Yue Gao (RUC_1)]<br />
+'''RCJ1''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/RCJ1.tgz Jia-Min Ren, Zhi-Sheng Chen, Jyh-Shing Roger Jang]<br />
+'''RCJ3''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/RCJ3.tgz Jia-Min Ren, Zhi-Sheng Chen, Jyh-Shing Roger Jang]<br />
+'''RCJ4''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/RCJ4.tgz Jia-Min Ren, Zhi-Sheng Chen, Jyh-Shing Roger Jang]<br />
+'''RK1''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/RK1.tgz Preeti Rao, Sujeet Kini]<br />
+'''SS''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/SS.tgz Klaus Seyerlehner, Markus Schedl]<br />
+'''TTOS''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/TTOS.tgz Emiru Tsunoo, George Tzanetakis, Nobutaka Ono, Shigeki Sagayama]<br />
+'''MTG1''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/MTG1.tgz N. Wack, E. Guaus, C. Laurier, O. Meyers, R. Marxer, D. Bogdanov, J. Serrà, P. Herrera (false, rca)]<br />
+'''MTG3''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/MTG3.tgz N. Wack, E. Guaus, C. Laurier, O. Meyers, R. Marxer, D. Bogdanov, J. Serrà, P. Herrera (false, simca)]<br />
+'''MTG4''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/MTG4.tgz N. Wack, E. Guaus, C. Laurier, O. Meyers, R. Marxer, D. Bogdanov, J. Serrà, P. Herrera (true, simca)]<br />
+'''MTG5''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/MTG5.tgz N. Wack, E. Guaus, C. Laurier, O. Meyers, R. Marxer, D. Bogdanov, J. Serrà, P. Herrera (false, svm)]<br />
+'''XLZZG''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/XLZZG.tgz Jieping Xu, Yi Liu, Tao Zheng, Chao Zhen, Yue Gao (RUC_1)]<br />
+'''XZZ''' = [https://music-ir.org/mirex/results/2009/audiogenre/XZZ.tgz JiePing Xu, Chao Zhen, Tao Zheng (RUC_2)]<br />
-'''TTOS''' [[ Emiru Tsunoo,Geroge Tzanetakis,Nobutaka Ono,Shigeki Sagayama]]
+==Run Times==
-'''GLR'''   [[ A. Grecu, T. Lidy, A. Rauber]]
+<csv>2009/mood.runtime.csv</csv> TBA

Difference between revisions of "2009:Audio Genre Classification (Mixed Set) Results"

Latest revision as of 15:02, 23 July 2010

Contents

Introduction

General Legend

Team ID

Overall Summary Results

Raw Classification Accuracy Averaged Over Three Train/Test Folds

Accuracy Across Folds

Accuracy Across Categories

Friedman's Tests for Significant Differences

Classes vs. System Tukey-Kramer HSD Multi-Comparisons

Folds vs. Systems Tukey-Kramer HSD Multi-Comparison

Hierarchical-Discounted Scoring Results

Results By Algorithm

Run Times

Navigation menu

Views

Personal tools

MIREX by Year

Results by Year

Account Request

Search

Navigation

Tools